What's Going On: What good is a voice if you can’t use it

Red Oak has a problem.

In our ever evolving/changing culture, moral relativism is becoming more and more vogue.

Either consciously or subconsciously, we are being trained to think it’s not right to judge the actions of others. For right or wrong, we are being conditioned to be accepting and tolerant of other’s behaviors to a level that would be incomprehensible 50 years ago.

Maybe that’s society evolving or devolving depending on your personal perspective. 

Drug addicts and alcoholics are portrayed as people with diseases, no longer the weak individual with a problem.

Unwed teenage mothers are no longer ostracized from home, community, school and church. Instead of maintaining homes for teenage moms, we make reality television programs about them.

And then there’s homosexuality. One of the most controversial of social issues, with ongoing arguments in the U.S. Supreme Court, advocates push for open acceptance of the gay and lesbian lifestyle, up to and including the right to marry.

Imagine that happening in 1963. Imagining openly gay couples in public places beyond the most liberal of communities is even incomprehensible.

But today, even if Christians do condemn the behavior as a sin in their personal religion, they are taught to at the very least tolerate the lifestyle to the point where all criticisms of it should never be publicly voiced.

Whether it’s chemical dependency, teen pregnancy or homosexuality, our society has become more sympathetic to the individual and far less judgmental of the action. Regardless of your belief if this is the right or wrong approach, it is the way our society has, and is, changing every day.

However, this moral relativism isn’t contained to discussions of social issues. I’m starting to see this unwillingness to openly disagree in many facets of our society, including ones where discussion, debate and disagreements are vital.

Red Oak is currently immersed in this kind of environment where people are literally afraid to be a dissenting voice. When people are afraid to disagree, that’s a problem.

This environment was never more apparent than at last week’s tourism committee meeting in which various funding proposals were discussed.

One came from the City Council, which approves the Mayor’s appointments to the board. If I’m sitting on a board, and I receive a funding request from the entity that placed me on the board (and can thus remove me), human nature dictates I will probably look more favorably on that proposal than on one sent from someplace else.

However, that belief is only heightened in this specific instance as the Mayor has disbanded this board in the past, only to form a new one with members who wholeheartedly agreed with his goals.

So when the Council sent a $12,400 funding request for a controversial promotional video, I questioned how this committee would react. Thanks to the company’s past legal missteps, which has resulted in multiple investigations by the Florida Attorney General (including one that is ongoing), the video proposal has not been well received by the community. It would stand to reason this committee, which represents a cross-section of that community, would include members who harbor similar reservations and objections.

But would they feel comfortable expressing those reservations, knowing such dissent could result in their removal?

Well, at their meeting several members did at least question the proposal, including new board member Angie Britten, who asked if the City is sidestepping the parameters for receiving funding. Those parameters dictate the sponsoring agency (in this case, the City) pay half of the project costs. Whether the city is doing that or not is a point of contention, related to whether the $12,400 from the Chamber and Industry Association would count towards that 50 percent requirement.

Regardless, committee members had multiple reasons to oppose this project and not fund it fully.

And at least one committee member, Deb Crouse, felt strongly enough to vote no against the funding compromise of providing the City a little more than $8,000.

What’s most concerning isn’t the vote itself, but Crouse’s reaction. She asked board chair and council member Jeanice Lester if she intended on telling the council who voted no.

She didn’t want them to know, worrying she might be removed from the committee as other dissenters have in the past.

Regardless of what I think, or you think, or anyone for that matter thinks about this video or any other issue that comes before the City, when people are afraid to vote their conscious, there’s a problem.

During a candidate’s forum before his election as mayor, Bill Billings stated “I plan to bring the community together and let the 95 percent of people who haven’t been given a voice the last two terms here in the City of Red Oak to have a voice to speak about every voted on subject that comes before the City Council. This is a democracy of the people, for the people, by the people, and the people have been shut out of the decision making process of this community.”

I wholeheartedly supported Billings in that effort then and even more so now.

But if that was truly a goal of his, it is one that is unmet. The people may have a voice, but they are afraid to use it.

And that’s a big problem.

Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express and Glenwood Opinion-Tribune. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here