What's Going On: School board’s choices: something between bad, worse

Red Oak’s school board will make a no-win decision at its April 13 budget hearing. 

No matter what is decided that night, they will have made a mistake … a mistake months in the making. 

The school board essentially has two options. They can either A: succumb to public pressure and remove the debt service levy, essentially stopping the Tigervision project; or B: ignore the desires of what I anticipate to be a large, vociferous crowd, subsequently turning them into a large, hostile crowd. 

Either way, the school board loses in terms of credibility and further exasperates a public relations nightmare that started at a public meeting in December, 2014. 

At that meeting, the board voted 3-2 to forge ahead with phase one of the Tigervision project, a $13 million construction project that will result in the relocation of the middle school to the high school campus. 

As it will be paid for with future sales tax dollars, the project doesn’t need a public vote, much to the dismay of many who spoke at that December meeting. They couldn’t comprehend how the district could embark on such a large project without the consent of the voters, and many of them wanted to have their say at the polls. 

I remember several weeks prior when the board planned that public meeting. I don’t believe they really expected many, if anyone, to attend. And why should they? During the previous half dozen or so public meetings in which the Tigervision project was devised and discussed at length, I could count the number of non-staff/committee members on one hand. 

But, the crowds came out, and despite their opposition the board continued on its seemingly predetermined path. 

Now, five months later, many of those same people are complaining about the school budget and its accompanying tax levy.

They have valid complaints. 

After the public passed the bond levy in 1999 to pay for Inman’s construction, they also soon passed a county-wide sales tax with the promise funds from the sales tax would pay for the new elementary school. 

That happened until 2014 when the school board decided to pay the remaining debt through property taxes to free up those sales tax dollars for the eventual Tigervision project. 

As a result, Red Oak’s levy remains high compared to other schools in the Hawkeye 10 conference and throughout the state. Had that debt service levy been removed, as initially promised and practiced, the levy would be about average compared to the rest of the state, instead of in the top 25 percent. 

So now, at the April 13 budget hearing, the school board will be criticized for its previous actions that have kept the levy high, while also enabling the district to build a $13 million building without voter approval and without additional tax increases. 

As a taxpayer and parent, I believe the board made a mistake at that December meeting. In fact, two weeks before I urged the board in this same column to give the voters a chance to approve the entire $28 million project that would consolidate the current five campuses to two. 

Maybe I was being naive, but I truly thought there was a chance to get that passed. 

I don’t believe, though, the board members, or at least the three that voted to pursue just phase one, shared that optimism. I think they felt that completing this first phase was the best and most realistic option available, so they took advantage of it. They saw an opportunity to improve the educational facilities for our students without the burden of additional taxes. 

While I didn’t agree with the decision, I could respect it. Had they gone to the public to vote on the entire project, and it failed, they really would have looked like heels had they then decided to implement phase one. 

So come next Monday, after the onslaught of criticism and negative comments, the board will be faced with that no-win decision. 

And while I may not have agreed with their initial decision to do this without a public vote, I hope they don’t change their mind now. 

The decision has been made, the path has been chosen, and it should be followed. 

Yes, as the front page article indicates, our taxes are higher than average. But they have been for several years now, and if we want to grow as a district, if we want what’s best for our children and our community, we need to continue to live with that reality. 

Closing the middle school and eventually consolidating into two campuses will create real financial savings for the district (estimated at $600K a year) which in turn will result in lower operating costs and thus, a lower levy. 

But that’s looking long term, beyond the here and now. 

Right now, the board has to decide what’s more important: futilely trying to regain public approval or moving the district forward. 

I hope they make the right decision this time. 

Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express and Glenwood Opinion-Tribune. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com. 

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here