The Sherman File, Pt. 2: Secret taping, consultant disagreement at heart of firing; teaching position offered

When Red Oak Superintendent Terry Schmidt recommended the school board not renew Jedd Sherman’s contract, he specifically cited the high school principal’s failure to meet two specific remediation targets identified in a previous evaluation. 

While the school board expanded the reasons for Sherman’s termination to five, they largely stemmed from the two original failed remediation targets.

The specific targets Schmidt cited were:

Develop a “culture of learning” that is “conducive to student learning and staff professional development;”

And, “promoting the success of all students by acting with integrity, fairness and in an ethical manner,” with an emphasis on teamwork with colleagues.

In his written assessment of how Sherman failed to meet those goals, Schmidt was precise with his criticism, citing two specific instances: Sherman secretly taping an administrators meeting in August 2013, which he denied doing when confronted, and an argument with a consultant that resulted in her refusing to work in  the high school as long as Sherman was principal. 

Secret Taping

Sherman said he began tape recording conversations between himself and Schmidt following a 2012 computer hacking incident.

After he filed a police report, Sherman claims he was told by a district employee he was going to be placed on administrative leave for his actions.

Police informed Sherman Iowa law allows an individual to record conversations without others consent, and he began doing so between himself and Schmidt. He also recorded meetings Schmidt conducted that included other administrators. 

During one such meeting Aug. 12, 2013 that included Schmidt and fellow administrators Nate Perrien, Gayle Allensworth, Barb Sims, Jeff Spotts and Technology Director Bob Deter, the hidden recorder started playing. When confronted about it, Sherman denied he was taping the meeting. 

As Iowa allows taping a conversation without both parties knowing it, and no district policy prohibiting it, Sherman said he felt uncomfortable admitting he was in fact recording the meeting.

“I was uncomfortable with the situation and didn’t want to discuss my relationship with Terry in front of others,” Sherman said. 

Following the August 2013 meeting, the district adopted a policy prohibiting employees from taping conversations and meetings, at which time Sherman said he discontinued the practice.
Regardless, the incident and Sherman’s denial resulted in alienation from his fellow administrators while providing Schmidt material for some of his harshest criticisms.

In his review of Sherman’s progress on the remediation target relating to working with integrity, Schmidt wrote “Jedd Sherman does not have a collegial, positive working relationship with any member of the district’s leadership team … the incident of Aug. 12, 2013 involving a blatant lie and unprofessional conduct … has not been rectified. No apology has been given to any administrator nor has any effort been generated to improve personal working relationships. There continues to be an atmosphere of distrust and lack of respect for Jedd Sherman by members of this district’s leadership team.”

Sherman maintains he was subjected to harassment and “bullying” by Schmidt and that the recordings were necessary to verify that. 

During one of those secretly taped conversations in June 2013, Schmidt offers Sherman a Spanish teaching position at his current administrator salary of $87,500.

On the audio tape, Sherman can be heard laughing at the offer as he now states it was inappropriate on several levels, starting with he’s not licensed to teach Spanish and only had six hours of college classes related to the subject, taken in 1987. Then there was the issue of paying him an administrators’ salary for a teaching position. 

When asked if he offered Sherman a teaching position in place of that as an administrator, Schmidt declined to comment, citing the confidentiality of the conversation. 

One of Sherman’s attorneys, Joe Wearin, sent a letter to Board President Lee Fellers asking if Schmidt was authorized by the school board to make such an offer. According to a letter provided to the Express, Fellers stated Schmidt did in fact have that ability to offer a teaching position but that the board would have to approve the reclassification of Sherman from an administrator to a teacher. 

However, Sherman maintains it was conversations just like that one that prompted him to start the secret recordings. 

And once the school board prohibited taping conversations through a policy, Sherman said he stopped doing it. 

 Working With Outside Consultants

Sherman’s file indicated he worked specifically with two consultants, Keri Aistrope with the Area Education Agency and Geri Parscale.

The district was working with both to help implement a program called Response to Intervention, which was designed to help the schools identify students with deficiencies in math and reading skills.

Red Oak started implementing the program in 2012, and Aistrope was then praising Sherman for his work. Sherman said this was largely due to the fact that Red Oak High School was the only one in southwest Iowa implementing the program which was primarily used at the elementary school level.

“This is the first HS (high school) … that has stretched this far, way ahead of your conference schools,” Aistrope told Sherman via an email. “I had a hard time envisioning what it would look like in an HS and now it seems so clear.”

Full implementation of the program was delayed due to various reasons, including scheduling conflicts and uncertainty over what universal screener to use to help identify students in need of additional assistance.

Parscale was hired by the district to help identify and implement a universal screener and work with the RTI program. She met with Sherman and other administrators several times, including an on-site audit Dec. 5, 2013.

Referred to as a “data collection interview” in Sherman’s recent evaluation, Schmidt stated “Sherman was not cooperative in the data collection by failing to answer questions and wanting to divert attention by asking the interviewer questions about unrelated matter.”

According to Parscale, Sherman “was continuing to rant about things that do not have anything to do with anything related to RTI.”

Schmidt further stated Sherman’s “disregard for (Parscale’s) professional role is more than unsatisfactory – it is a direct violation of ethical expectations.”

He also said Parscale has “respectfully declined to pursue any additional consultation at Red Oak High School while Jedd Sherman is in a leadership position.”

Sherman maintains the “data” Parscale was attempting to collect was more of an evaluation of him as an administrator.

He said he simply wanted to read her survey questions and she refused to provide them. In addition, the meeting was scheduled to last 15 minutes and the material being assessed was not based on the professional development provided in a summer training session. Her evaluation did not align with previous established guidelines.

Sherman did not receive the results of the Dec. 5 survey until March 12. 

Sherman also points out the high school is the only one in the district that has not been identified by the state as a school “in need of assistance” for the past six years, a designation reserved for schools with a large number of students with reading and mathematic deficiencies.

By contrast, the middle school has received this designation four consecutive years in both math and reading, two years at Washington Intermediate, and one year at Inman, where RTI has been implemented.

What’s Next

During its June 9 meeting, the Red Oak School Board met in closed session for more than an hour. After emerging from that session, the board voted to direct its counsel to proceed with the direction they agreed upon in closed session.

When asked to elaborate further, Schmidt stated it was regarding a pending personnel dispute but would not confirm it involved Sherman. 

Regardless, unless the district and Sherman reach a settlement, this controversy appears to be headed to a courtroom where an administrative judge will determine whether the board was justified in not renewing the contract. 

The hearing is scheduled for July 2-3 in Red Oak, although an exact location has yet to be determined. 

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here