Reader comments on "doer" letter

 Dear Mr. Orear,

 I must say I am disappointed and appalled that a person who has no acquaintance with Jennifer Horner and quite possibly has never even been in our community could be allowed space on the page to say terrible things about a local citizen. To say that she is the reason that babies will not see an Iowa sunrise or the veiled comparison to Hitler is horrific.

I was also somewhat disappointed with your article naming her as the “black sheep” of our community as I am not even sure of your relationship with her, Mr. Orear.  Mr. Goodmote didn’t seem to receive any such label.  I think I understood your point, but I question your objectivity and motive. I think you should apologize to her as it seems you have now made her a target.

 Please inform those at odds with Jenny’s “doing” that she does quite a lot in our community.  I would say she is one of the main, if not the main, person who assists the Latino community.  She assists with the food pantry, a community garden and numerous other local community efforts.  I would encourage anyone to show their list of things that they do for the community and put that up next to Jennifer Horner’s. I can’t imagine there are many who would have a list as long. I am not acquainted with Mr. Goodemote and will not speak poorly of him but I do wonder if there are positive things that he does in his community.  I hope that he does and I hope they are not solely politically and religiously motivated.   

Regarding abortion, I suppose I will throw in my two cents.  I had a severely disabled son who died last October at 11 years old.  I was given the option for an abortion prior to his birth and it wasn’t something that I could do personally; however, I cannot pass judgment on those who do.  My son’s life was a very difficult one for him and for our family but I wouldn’t have had it any other way – he could not sit up, swallow or even breathe without assistance. I would not judge someone else for making a different choice nor would I tell them they were wrong for doing it.  None of us know what someone else is going through and should not judge them for their choices.  Maybe we should look a little deeper into people’s lives before we decide who they are.  It’s so easy to pass judgment from afar. 

Sincerely,

Carrie Shalters, Red Oak

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here