Let’s not be in a hurry to close Gitmo

About a month ago an active duty military personnel I met on the Honor Flight to Washington D.C. shared his thoughts about the whole “Guantanamo” deal, the methods of interrogation and whether or not it ought to be closed. He said Girmo had saved American and other’s lives and we Americans shouldn’t forget some “enemies” don’t have prison camps – they just kill those captured.

I’ve read some from the dissenting opinions of Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Scalia for the June 2008 Supreme Court decision that gutted the previously establish system offering a form of judicial review to detainees at Guantanamo. I was sobered by Scalia’s final statement: “The Nation will live to regret what the Court has done today. I dissent.”

Guantanamo, leased since 1903, seems to be a legal minefield. Because of September 11, legal questions come without precedent. The president and congress do have the power to act to protect Americans. Our military defends itself, the country it serves, and detains those suspected of interfering with successful operations. In the case of Gitmo, suspects from over 40 nations were sent to Gitmo. Al Qaeda works with the Taliban in countries around the world. Individuals aren’t always from an “army” so Geneva Convention isn’t necessarily applicable according to some lawyers.

Judges recently decided lease means “own.”

People suspected of terrorism first arrived at Gitmo in January 02. We’ve systematically released many. I hope most were innocent. Americans have been killed by some released from Gitmo.

The whole habeas corpus question is interesting. History and lower courts concluded it didn’t apply to non-citizen enemy combatants. As Chief Justice Roberts asks, if we give non-citizens one right, what other rights are we granting? And for the detainees, who gathers the evidence? Do we pull active duty personnel to testify – and at what price militarily? Who volunteers to carry the subpoena into a war zone to look for those willing to travel and testify in another country? How credible will the witnesses be?

If convicted, what prison takes the condemned? Countries are refusing detainees we’re willing to move. And does the current ruling in effect tell our military that while they carry out orders they must also be giving Miranda rights or stop and document actions in the midst of a battle?

May 9/11 forced us to “wing” a few things, but we had systems in place to be used as carefully as legal counsel allowed. Dissenting opinion reminds us that there is no legal history to warrant the conclusion our Supreme Court has reached.

Let’s not be in a hurry to close an improved facility that is more fully understanding its occupants.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here