Free health insurance for government workers should end

If Terry Branstad runs for a 38th term as Iowa’s governor, he may actually have my vote, regardless of what he does with the remainder of his term.

Last week, Branstad said he would again push for state legislation that would require elected officials to pay for 20 percent of their health care costs.

According to Branstad, 84 percent of state employees pay nothing for their insurance.

“If you look at most private sector (companies), employees pay at least 20 percent,” Branstad said. “Some pay more than that and, obviously, if you’re a farmer or self-employed, you pay 100 percent.”

This kind of fiscal responsibility is sorely lacking not only in Des Moines, but Red Oak as well.

Currently, city employees don’t have to pay for individual health insurance, an expense that is expected to cost the City $511,000 next year. That’s up from $372,000 just a few years ago.

All companies have to compensate for, and adjust to rising costs, such as health insurance.

But typically, that requires shared sacrifice on the part of the employee, unless of course you have the good fortune of working for the government.

In the real world of small business, when a fixed expense like health insurance increases, you can do one of two things: cut other expenses, which is always painful, or try to raise revenues, which can be probelmatic in a recession.

But if you work for the government, raising revenues is easy. All you have to do is raise everyone’s taxes.

So for government employees, instead of having to spend more money out of their checks for insurance, their employer can simply protect them by taking more money out of our pockets when it comes time to pay taxes.

And that stinks.

I fully understand the need for jobs in the public sector to offer wages and benefits comparable to those in the private sector.

But in the private sector, the day of fully-funded health insurance is gone. In fact, it’s been gone for a long, long time.

With Red Oak slated to spend $511,000 on insurance this year, if employees were required to pay the national average of 30 percent of those costs, the city would have an additional $170,000 to spend on items such as additional police officers, library workers, and funding for the YMCA.

Or perhaps they could even collect $170,000 less in taxes.

Of course, as Branstad has discovered, Red Oak’s council can’t simply decide to start charging employees for insurance.

Red Oak’s police and fire departments both are union affiliated. As such, the City has always attempted to extend the same terms to all city employees, if not for any other reason, to give them no motivation to form their own union.

And naturally, negotiating this employee-concession through a union would be no small task.

So unless the police and fire are willing to de-certify, another highly unlikely possibility, the City will most likely continue to be financially hamstrung with this extravagant job benefit.

And it will be the average taxpayer, who in addition to paying for his own health care, that will get to foot the bill for someone else’s insurance as well.

Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here