Consolidation—A cure for ailing communities or just a placebo?

As a former member of the Stanton school and community, I am well aware of the mixed feelings associated with consolidation.

In fact it's a common subject every year when it's time for the standardized tests.

All through school the teachers gently reminded us that these tests didn't affect our grades but were still very important.

As we got older we started to understand that these tests helped the state determine how the school was  doing and if it was cost efficient to keep the school open.  

Instead of putting pressure on us, it gave us a strange sense of pride, like we were  using these tests to defend our school.  After all, did we really want to have to mix in with the other schools?

As the debate rages on its blatantly  clear that the "my town, my school" mentality is still there, as some people are refusing the merger solely based  on the fact that it is happening with a rival town.  

Other people are looking at the situation from the view that it's in the best interest of both towns and people are letting their pride get in the way.  

I think both sides are missing the big picture.

Money is what's important here. The plan to consolidate is based on the idea that it's cheaper to run one large school rather than two small schools, especially if the test scores of those schools aren't showing any signs that the size of the school affects the quality of its academic structure.

That  idea would be good enough if both schools involved had the funding they deserved and were still failing academically, but that is simply not the case.

It's no surprise that the little schools in the area aren't getting the money they need to run effectively because it's common knowledge that the educational industry is underfunded in general.  

This consolidation would only serve as a band aid for a much larger issue.

The question is where does  it stop? If we allow this to happen we're accepting that it's ok to cut back  on education funds which are needed to give the students up to date material, good learning environments and pay the teachers that have dedicated their lives to help prepare our children for the future.

If the teachers are forced to use sub standard material in a underfunded facility then it seems only logical that their interest would fade.

Who really wants to work for no pay in this economy?

If the teachers stop caring, the students stop caring.

When the students stop caring the grades fall, which leads to more budget cutting and more consolidations.  

Instead of strolling down the road that could lead to massive schools full of unhappy  people and uneducated kids, why not turn our focus back on our governor and  start asking him a few questions, like why he can't spend some of the extra  taxes he placed on tobacco sales to update books?

If he is so worried that the post office and the workforce locations are costing too much money, why  not take what would be spent in keeping them open and applying it to schools  instead?

I was a Viking and I learned to appreciate the knowledge  that hard work and determination are what solves problems, not quick fixes.

Small schools offer  students the opportunity of having a class that feels like a family in an institution that feels like a home and when used correctly can yield incredibly smart and talented kids.

Education is important, more important  than this debate is letting on. It's time to put away old rivalries and local pride so that we can protect these academic environments.

Adams is a graduate of Stanton High School. You can contact him at d_adams07@live.com

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here