What's Going On: Survey surprisingly brands farmers as an optimistic lot

After spending nearly all of my adult life in small, agriculture-based communities in the Midwest, I’ve had the opportunity to get to know several farmers on a personal basis; in fact, I even married a farmer’s daughter.

In my experience, farmers are generally conservative and seemingly pessimistic by nature. They worry a lot, a by-product of relying on a lot of factors that are out of their control (commodity prices, seed prices, mother nature, etc.) for their livelihood.

However, a recent study by the Iowa State University Extension not only challenges the notion farmers are pessimistic, but actually asserts they may be optimists at heart.

Since 1982, the Iowa State University Extension and Outreach has conducted its annual Farm and Rural Life Poll.

Of the 2,219 surveys mailed, nearly 1,300 were returned with most of those coming from individuals who said their farming represented more than half of their total household income.

Of those responses, more than half (54 percent) agreed their families’ quality of life had improved, while only 10 percent believed it had worsened. They are also cautiously optimistic about the future with 32 percent believing their families’ quality of life will continue to improve during the next five years, compared to 13 percent who expect life to get worse.

Coincidentally, or not, that first five year window aligns with the Democrats rise to power, specifically that of President Barack Obama. And much of the next five years aligns with his second term, possibly explaining the tepid optimism for further improvement.

What’s even more interesting, and possibly revealing of today’s farmer’s mindset, is comparing survey results to the first one conducted in 1982.

A strong argument could be made that 2012 resembled 1982 in the sense that the country was just recovering from a serious economic downturn.

In 1982, unemployment and inflation were both in double digits and interest rates were near 20 percent. By comparison, inflation was just 3 percent in 2012 while the jobless rate was around 8 percent and interest rates were a fraction of where they were three decades ago.

So when they were asked to rate how important certain issues were, inflation, interest rates and unemployment didn’t rank nearly as high in 2012 as they did in 1982.

In fact, not much did.

Inflation was either important or very important to 90 percent of respondents in 1982; interest rates were at 94 percent and unemployment was at 82 percent.

In 2012, the biggest concern was “young people not being able to start farming” at 82 percent, down from 89 percent in 1982. No other issue ranked higher than 68 percent (market concentration of large-scale agribusiness).

This tells me farmers aren’t nearly as fidgety as they were 30 years ago. Their industry has somewhat stabilized.

Each year’s survey varies slightly in some of the questions, allowing it to change with whatever is happening in the world of agriculture.

With land values skyrocketing the last few years, the 2012 survey focused a lot on that issue, and some of the responses were very interesting.

Farmers overwhelmingly agreed (68 percent) that land values are too high and can’t be sustained at these levels, while 66 percent believed values are much higher than the land is actually worth.

However, despite this strong belief that land is too pricey, more than 60 percent of farmers still believe Iowa cropland is still a good investment.

So in short, Iowa farmers believe life has been good lately, and will probably get better tomorrow, despite skyrocketing land values.

Living in a community that relies so heavily on agriculture, that kind of optimism should be encouraging to all of us.

Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express and Glenwood Opinion-Tribune. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here