What's Going On: Property tax relief is no reason to support gas tax

At the recent Farm and Home Show, three Republican southwest Iowa legislators (as if there are any other kind) touted a gas tax increase as the solution to the state’s alleged crumbling highway system.

I should note I say alleged because this entire argument is predicated upon the fact that Iowa’s highways are in comparatively worse shape than similar states. I have driven a lot of Missouri, Nebraska and Iowa highways and find Iowa and Nebraska’s in much better shape condition wise than our neighbor to the south. But as indicated, I’m no expert.

So I’ll accept the notion Iowa’s highways are in poorer condition than they should be, and according to Representatives Mark Costello and Cecil Dolechek and Sen. Joni Ernst, a gas tax is the way to fix them.

At first, I was surprised to hear three Republicans all support a tax increase so uniformly. Republicans usually are the ones opposing tax hikes.

And apparently, the state GOP party has come out opposing the increase while Republican Gov. Terry Branstad is lukewarm at best to the proposal.

What puzzled me even more though was that these lawmakers represented a rural portion of the state. I quickly learned in Missouri that gas taxes were bad news for rural residents as they got to pay their share, but most of the funds went to urban-area projects.

However, Sen. Ernst explained in Iowa, all funds raised through gas taxes are distributed through a statewide funding formula, ensuring the money is distributed evenly based on population.

That seems fair and it certainly explains why three rural lawmakers would support such a proposal. It would also explain why their fellow Republicans from urban areas would oppose it. They want funding based on subjective decisions and priorities that can frequently leave us wanting for more.

Regardless though, the good Senator from Red Oak also explained Gov. Branstad has indicated he won’t be supporting the gas tax unless his property tax relief package is approved for the first time in three years.

So the rest of the weekend I was running some numbers in my head. Property tax on my average-sized home is about $1,000 a year, so if we had say, a modest 5 percent decrease in property taxes, it would save me about $50 a year, or $4.16 a month.

The proposed gas tax would result in an eventual 10-cent a gallon increase. I don’t drive a lot so I’d estimate my monthly consumption is about 30 gallons a month. So the gas tax increase would result in an extra $3 in my fuel bill.

So in other words, I might save $14 a year if there was a 5 percent drop in property tax.

Enough to buy a large pizza and a couple cokes from Cubbys.

Well, at least that made a little sense to me why Gov. Branstad would insist on a tax cut before he increased taxes. He wants some relief for the Average Joe, like you and me.

Except here’s the rub: the property tax relief Branstad is stumping for is primarily geared toward commercial property owners, so really, there will be no relief for the Average Joe, just another tax increase.

Some proponents of the governor’s tax relief package will point to provisions that might cap future tax increases by changing school funding practices, but at this point, there are no real numbers to assign to it.

And regardless, property tax relief does nothing to help those who own no property, who typically, can’t afford a gas tax increase to begin with.

A gasoline tax is essentially a tax on a commodity. Even if you don’t drive a car you most certainly rely on services where fuel consumption is a major expense driver.

When fuel prices go up, the price of basically everything goes up with it.

Right now, Gov. Branstad is essentially saying he will support this tax increase as long as he gets one of his own agenda items pushed through. It’s the classic “you scratch my back, I’ll scratch yours,” ploy used by politicians for centuries.

It’s unfortunate, though, that an issue this important that will be so burdensome on so many is being considered so frivolously.

Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express and Glenwood Opinion-Tribune. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here