What's Going On: Preventive surgery: Has anyone asked if this should be done?
Ordinarily, when a Hollywood celebrity undergoes plastic surgery, I don’t pay attention.
But if you pardon the vulgarity, this is no ordinary boob job.
Renowned actress Angelina Jolie announced last week she underwent a double mastectomy in order to reduce her chance of contracting breast cancer.
Through developments in genetic testing, for about $3,000, women can be screened for a genetic mutation that indicates a higher likelihood of developing breast and ovarian cancer by upwards of 80-90 percent.
Jolie, whose mother had died of breast cancer, decided to be tested and the mutation was detected. She was told she had an 85 percent chance of developing a similar aggressive strand of breast cancer.
With the surgery, her chances are now less than five percent.
“I wanted to write this to tell other women that the decision to have a mastectomy was not easy,” Jolie wrote in a New York Times opinion piece. “I can tell my children that they don’t need to fear they will lose me to breast cancer.“
Cancer is a very scary disease and breast cancer specifically has affected the lives of millions of women, including my own sister who’s undergone surgery, chemotherapy and is now halfway through radiation treatments.
I have seen first hand the horrors this disease can bring on a person and their loved ones.
With that in mind, I can understand why Jolie would pursue a procedure as invasive as a mastectomy. And based on surveys that have cited anywhere from 50-65 percent of women would do the same as Jolie, it’s obvious the actress’ approach isn’t that unconventional.
But trying to take out the emotion surrounding the specific medical condition this procedure addresses, I have to ask this question: Even if we can safely conduct preventive surgery like this, should we?
From Lasik to unneeded c-sections, elective surgery is becoming more common. Medical advances have hastened this as what used to be a major procedure requiring several days of recovery in a hospital now is done with a laser and a local anesthesia, sending the patient home in just a few hours, possibly without a scar.
Even the most natural process of giving birth is being scheduled as c-sections are performed because a mother likes a certain date or wants the oddity of naming her daughter Tuesday even though she was born Thursday.
And while research has shown the numerous risks incurred with c-sections, the numbers of them increase.
What Jolie has done, though, is taken this to a whole new level. The line in the sand has been moved back one more step.
First, we have to consider she didn’t have cancer, at least not yet. Sure, there was an 85 percent chance. That means there was a 15 percent chance she would never get it.
Secondly, those numbers are construed in today’s modern world. One doctor, when asked why women like Jolie pursue a double mastectomy in this scenario responded “right now the most effective prevention that we have for [this] BRCA mutation carrier is a prophylactic double mastectomy.”
Right now. Did you catch those two words? They are very important words because we don’t know what medical advances will be made tomorrow, or next week, or next year. Maybe Jolie contracts breast in 10 years, but what if in eight, some genetic engineering advancement is discovered to reverse the mutation and prevent the cancer from occurring? Or if we really want to dream big, whose to say cancer won’t have a cure by then, or at least some form of it.
We just don’t know, just like Jolie doesn’t know if she will ever contract the disease.
Again, I don’t want to attack Jolie or anyone who chooses this procedure. Ultimately, it’s their choice. I don’t know what point the risk is high enough to choose surgery. I wonder about the ovarian cancer risk. Will she also undergo a hysterectomy next or are the chances not high enough? If they aren’t, what is high enough to choose surgery? Seventy-percent? Sixty-five? Fifty? Two?
This also brings up another series of questions for the 99.9 percent of the population who can’t afford to pay for a major surgical procedure like a mastectomy out of their bank accounts, or even a $3,000 test, if their insurance doesn’t cover it. At some point, some pencil pusher and cost analysis accountant will decide if its cheaper to pay for X cancer patients’ treatments or Y number of preventive surgeries. I’m not comfortable with that conversation, which could extend to other diseases.
Surgery is a big deal I think we take too lightly at times. Major procedures, like mastectomies and c-sections carry inherit risks. Anytime you are put under, there’s always a chance you don’t wake up.
And while I can’t sit in judgment in anyone who chooses otherwise, I can’t help but believe less is better when it comes to surgery.
Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com.
