What's Going On: Jury trials provide unique insights

 Entering my third decade working in small town newspapers, there are a few events that are as invigorating today as they were when I first started working at a daily newspaper in Chillicothe, Mo., in 1993. 

If you love your job as I do, it’s because of moments like that. Enjoyable careers have them. They are what gets you out of bed every morning for 50 years and allows you to somewhat enjoy your work. 

People who dread going to work and hate their jobs don’t have those moments. 

I feel very fortunate I’m one of the former and not the latter. 

For me, walking on the sidelines of a meaningful high school football game is one of those moments. Taking pictures as an observer is a unique perspective for this event. 

With no disrespect to other sports, nothing like a big football game brings together a small town. The stands are packed. There’s a buzz in the community for days before and after (if the hometown team wins) and there is an atmosphere on game day that is truly electric. 

That same outside observer perspective to a tragedy is another one of those unique life moments I experience that are inherent to my job.

As much as I love and enjoy the atmosphere surrounding the football game, whenever I experience tragedy in its truest form, a sudden and unexpected death, an entirely different array of emotions surface.

Witnessing the tragedy, the grief on the faces of family and emergency responders alike always renews the emotional depths of how much I appreciate God’s blessings in my life. 

When I see someone suffering the ultimate despair associated with losing children in a fire, or an entire family to carbon monoxide poisoning I can’t help but grieve as well. That kind of emotional experience softens even the most hardened heart and that sort of upheaval is invigorating in an entirely different way compared to a football game. 

And a third very unique experience that is actually open to everyone to experience is witnessing a jury trial. 

If you have never been to one, you should go. Go to at least one. It doesn’t have to be a sensational, gory one. Any one will do. 

In my experience, they are all very interesting while providing insight into the inner workings of our justice system. 

The environment itself is unique with many formalities. Judges in robes, lawyers in suits, people standing and sitting as the jury enters, all inside a grand building and in the case of the Montgomery County courthouse, a stately, historically-rich room. 

In those regards, it’s very similar to a church. Just substitute the judge with the preacher and the lawyers with the deacons. The jury is your choir and then congregation sits in the gallery watching the show. 

But in stark contrast is what’s being said. If there’s a jury trial, there’s a good chance a crime of some sort has occurred and more than likely, if the case is in your local county courthouse, it involved some element of violence.   

Beyond the obvious though of what’s said, the accompanying theatrics and the pomp and circumstance is another strange dynamic. 

For those who are most intimately involved, the plaintiff and defendant, this is a rare, if not once-in-a-lifetime experience filled with tension, apprehension and even fear. 

Then there is those who are in the “process” on a routine basis. With the judge, lawyers and court reporters, there is an air of familiarity that is common to most work places. 

You don’t notice it while court is in session or when “on the record” discussions are ongoing. But when the jury leaves, the air of formality disappears. As a result, the judge and opposing lawyers act like normal co-workers do: they crack jokes, tell stories about their families, discuss plans for the weekend. Meanwhile, the defendant and his family sit stoically, not cracking a smile, wondering if their weekend plans include handcuffs and a prison term. 

Then, the jury comes back or the conversation goes “on the records” and the formality returns. 

And after the arguing is over and the jury goes into deliberations, there is never a moment in time with more tension than just before the verdict is read; a verdict that will likely greatly impact at least two different families. 

I’ve covered all sorts of trials, ranging from a 70-year-old woman who shot her husband with a high-powered rifle while he was fishing to a former mayor accused of burning down her own bar. Last week was probably the least heralded of all jury trials I’ve ever seen: a simple assault. 

There weren’t many people watching. No television crews in town or extra security. 

But even in its simplest form, it still had the basic tenants that make all jury trials so intriguing and definitely worth watching. 

Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express and Glenwood Opinion-Tribune. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com. 

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here