What's Going On: The hypocrisy of acceptable use of the n-word

 Riley Cooper said the word and was branded a racist.

Richie Incognito used the word and was branded a racist bully.

Matt Barnes used the word and was branded an emotional hothead. But not a racist.

Same word, different reaction. Why? Because Matt Barnes is recognized as being partially black.

Cooper and Incognito, both professional football players, are white and as such, apparently aren’t allowed to use the “n-word.” But Barnes, a professional basketball player who is a racial mix that includes the essential black component, can. Or at least, that’s the logic conveyed by many.

The dreaded n-word is certainly not a new one, tracing its roots to slavery in America when blacks were regarded as if they were cattle, hogs or chickens. It was simply another term used to refer to a specific kind of livestock.

And with all racist terms, its usage didn’t stop with the end of slavery. Used to demean and dehumanize, the word was still used rampantly, primarily by whites, as blacks were still treated as second-class citizens.

But then, something happened that turned the n-word upside down as it became something sacred to blacks, especially young ones.

That something is called rap music.

With the proliferation of the n-word in rap lyrics, its usage has become not only commonplace but also revered with young blacks, especially men. With rap music tracing its birth to the 1980s, those young black men are now old black men, bridging generational gaps for the n-word’s acceptability.

Again, if spoken by a black man.

That hypocrisy though puzzles me. If the n-word is vile and offensive when spoken by whites, how can it be any less disrespectful when spoken by a non-white?

Barnes’ situation makes it all the more complicated. He’s of mixed ancestry, which begs the question: at what percentage does a person have to be “black” before they can speak the word with reproach?

I watched a video last week in which a well-known white supremacist was informed on live television that about 10 percent of his genetic make-up was black. As a result, does he now qualify for entry into the “n-word” club?

Michael Wilbon, a black sports journalist whom I held in high regard, defended Barnes’ actions, adding he uses the n-word “all day, every day.” He further went on to compare NBA Commissioner David Stern, who is white, to a plantation owner if Stern were to attempt to discipline Barnes and as such, attempt to place parameters as to when black players can and can not use the n-word.

I find this comparison mind-blowing, especially considering its historical context. First, I’ll ignore the fallacy a boss (Stern) can’t dictate how employees (Barnes) communicate with co-workers and the public.

But to liken him to a plantation owner, a group that coined the phrase to begin with, simply because he wants its usage ended demonstrates how upside down the n-word and its partial acceptance has become.

Another sports journalist whom I’ve read for many years, Jason Whitlock, went as far as to claim the n-word has become a “cherished possession” among blacks.

“The n-word’s ascension to black America’s favorite word in the dictionary is alarming. How a person defines himself or herself determines how he or she will be treated by the world,” Whitlock wrote.

Another black “journalist,” NBA analyst Charles Barkley defended Wilbon’s stance, stating “white America don’t get to dictate how me and (colleague) Shaq (O’Neal) talk to each other.”

The only problem with that belief is if “white America” doesn’t get to dictate what words are acceptable for use in our society, then nobody else does either, and I’m not sure Barkley understands that.

If whites, like Stern, can’t come out and say the use of racist, demeaning language is unacceptable then there are no longer rules for civil discourse.

I remember a few years back Wilbon made a then-controversial remark about how black athletes didn’t want to play in Boston because of the city’s racist history.

Wilbon cited his own experience of covering Celtics’ games at which he was called the n-word.

Apparently, it wasn’t Barkley calling him that. Because then, it would have been okay.

But really, it wouldn’t have been, because no matter who says it, the word should never be used, by anyone.

Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express and Glenwood Opinion-Tribune. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com. 

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here