What's Going On: How several bad decisions can destroy lives, and a town
Maryville, Mo., is a town under attack.
Never before has this college town in northwest Missouri been under such an intense media spotlight as it has in the last week after an article appeared in the Oct. 13 edition of the Kansas City Star.
That front-page article detailed the events of an evening in January 2012; an evening that may very well define the lives of several young men and women and the direction of an entire community for years to come.
On that fateful night, Daisy Coleman, then 14, and a 13-year-old friend had a sleepover at Daisy’s house. Daisy had swiped some of her mother’s alcohol and the pair were drinking it while watching movies.
Daisy, a popular student at Maryville High School, was a cheerleader and member of a competitive dance squad. With a couple older brothers, she became acquainted with some of their friends, including a senior football player named Matthew Barnett.
Despite her older brother’s warnings to steer clear, Daisy started communicating with Barnett and on the night of the sleepover, was texting him.
To make a long story short, Barnett convinced the girls to sneak out of the house. He drove them to his parent’s home and sneaked them into the basement where there were four other teenage boys and alcohol.
Several hours later, Daisy awoke in a drunken stupor on her front porch, the victim of an alleged rape.
I say alleged because while Barnett was charged and arrested (along with another boy who had sex with the 13-year-old), all charges were dropped a few months later. In short, the boys admitted to having sex with the girls, but claimed it was consensual. However, the girls had been drinking and if they were intoxicated to the point of being incapacitated, Missouri law mandates they could not have given permission.
Regardless, the prosecutor dropped the charges claiming there wasn’t sufficient evidence for a conviction.
Needless to say, the case polarized the community and the girl and her siblings became the subject of scorn and ridicule. The mother was fired from her job as a veterinarian (although her boss claimed the rape charges had nothing to do with it) and the family eventually moved back to Albany, Mo. However, a few months after they moved, their empty house burned to the ground due to still unknown causes.
Many of the accused boys have graduated from high school and two are attending college in Maryville while Barnett enrolled in classes at Central Missouri State University.
But the Kansas City Star article reopened this wound, taking this case to a national and even international stage as newspapers, radio and television stations from around the world picked up the story.
As a result, after a week of intense scrutiny, the local prosecutor who dropped the charges more than a year ago, agreed to have a circuit judge appoint a special prosecutor to review the case and possibly re-file charges.
I’m not a legal expert and I certainly don’t know what happened in that basement 20 months ago. A prosecutor and possibly a jury will decide if a crime was committed and what a fitting punishment should be.
What I am certain of is this predicated the ordeal: a bunch of bad decisions.
If Matthew Barnett is found innocent and cleared of all charges, his reputation will still be tarnished for a long time. However, even if he is innocent in a legal sense, he is not blameless.
He made a bad decision by encouraging Daisy to sneak out of the house and drive her to his home. He made a bad decision by giving her alcohol when she got there. He made a bad decision when he decided to engage in a sexual encounter with her. And he made a bad decision when he left her on her porch, passed out, on a cold January morning.
But Daisy is not without blame as well, as she made her share of bad decisions as well, starting with ignoring her brother’s advice to steer clear of the older Barnett.
She made a bad decision when she decided to steal some alcohol from her mother and drink that night with the her 13-year-old friend, which surely impeded her judgment, causing the next bad decision of sneaking out of the house. She then made another bad decision when in a room full of boys agreed to drink not one, but two large glasses of alcohol.
Please don’t misunderstand me as I’m not attempting to justify anyone’s actions or place blame. Again, I don’t even know what really happened.
But in a few years, when my children get of the age when they are capable and able to sneak out of the house, or drink alcohol, or become interested in sex, this story will again be told.
Bad decisions have repercussions. They can affect your life and those around you for a long, long time.
That’s a lesson we can take from this and one we need to impress on our daughters and sons.
Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express and Glenwood Opinion-Tribune. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com.
