What's Going On: Heated abortion debate continues after 40 years
Last week, one of America’s most controversial Supreme Court cases, Roe v. Wade, marked its 40th anniversary.
If this country had a Mt. Rushmore of important Supreme Court cases, this one would be on it, right next to Brown vs. Board of Education, Dred Scott vs. Sanford and Hustler Magazine vs. Jerry Falwell.
If you believe the pro-life supporters’ figures, more than 55 million babies have been aborted since that 1973 case.
Regardless of the validity of that statistic, what can not be disputed is that abortion remains nearly as controversial a subject today as it was 40 years ago.
As with most controversial topics, each of America’s political parties has thoroughly entrenched itself on one side of the spectrum: the Democrats with the pro-choice camp and the Republicans with the pro-lifers.
And while we can watch from a distance some topics ebb and flow in their sea of controversy, there appears to be no cooling of the abortion debate.
Over time, we may even see a GOP-controlled Congress and Executive Branch manipulate the high court that would eventually lead to the reversal of the historic 1973 case.
The Republican and Christian in me would have no qualms with that. I believe all life is sacred, adhering to the principal that if only God can create life, only God can take it (which puts me squarely at odds with the GOP’s seemingly contradictory support of capital punishment, but I digress).
However, as I ponder a world in which abortion was again illegal, that number 55 million quickly resurfaces.
While it’s important to note illegally performed abortions were rampant before Roe V. Wade, for the sake of argument, let’s assume all of those 55 million legally aborted babies would have been born the last 40 years.
That’s a rate of about 1.4 million children a year.
That’s 1.4 million presumably unwanted children. Children born to single mothers. Children born to couples who were either financially or emotionally unable to raise a (another) child. Children born to parents who for whatever reason, didn’t believe themselves capable or willing to accept responsibility for another life.
I wonder if as a society we are prepared to deal with the ramifications of 55 million unwanted children. Much of our society now generally scorns those who reach out to the government for help, of which there would be a lot more.
This last presidential election highlighted the disgust that has bubbled beneath the surface for so many years towards those on Medicaid, food stamps and welfare. Suddenly, we are speaking words like “entitlements” under hushed breaths, as if we are referring to something vulgar or perverse.
We like to talk about welfare reform, which is sorely needed. But too often, our version of reform is simply cutting the budgets. Had those 55 million children been born the last 40 years, would we be more accepting of the deluge of single mothers and of more families living under the poverty line, needing food stamps and governmental help?
Would we suddenly be more receptive to higher taxes to pay for these dastardly entitlement programs that would be so much more in demand?
And if your solution to this growing problem is by having mothers put these unwanted children up for adoption, you are extremely naive.
Each state establishes its own guidelines on public adoption, resulting in a muddled mess and a private market where healthy babies and toddlers are essentially sold for tens of thousands of dollars through private adoption agencies.
Maybe saturating the market with 55 million more babies would drive those prices down, but regardless, leaving adoption practices up to each individual state would be a practice that has to change.
Interestingly, abortion rates have actually been declining nationwide for more than 10 years. What has increased the last 10 years, not coincidentally, is the availability of birth control through groups like Planned Parenthood in conjunction with additional sex education in the public school system.
The most effective way to prevent an abortion is to prevent the unwanted pregnancy from ever occurring, and even more access to birth control and sex education courses will be needed to do that.
So while banning abortion on the surface sounds like a great idea, the conservative regime so gung ho for that legislation better be ready for some unpleasant side affects of that action.
Because 55 million unwanted babies would create a lot of side effects.
Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express and Glenwood Opinion-Tribune. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com.
