What's Going On: Association board needs investor’s support today more than ever
More than two weeks ago, upon announcement of Darrel Steven Carlyle’s resignation as Executive Director of the Chamber and Industry Association, I recommended the 13-member board resign and a smaller one reform.Since then, the board has met three times to discuss the organization’s future, wasting time with topics ranging from job titles to the ludicrous kidnapping of a laptop. And in spite of the mind-numbing number of irrelevant topics debated and argued, one fact remains clear: The Chamber and Industry Association board is completely dysfunctional.This is a train wreck happening in slow motion right before our own eyes and nothing is actually being done to prevent it.Some people are trying to stop it. Suggestions encouraging the board to dissolve and reform with five or seven members have been communicated in several manners, publicly and privately, but are simply pleasantly acknowledged and passively ignored without consideration.Meanwhile, a conglomeration of individuals, most of which aren’t even on the board, are promoting separate agendas that in one way or another weaken the Association’s board and the now vacant Executive Director position.And unfortunately, the only way to prevent the cockroaches from devouring the house is to blow it up.The guiding principle behind combining the Chamber with the Industrial Association is as innovative and open-minded as it is effective and appropriate in a community the size of Red Oak.But for that philosophy to blossom as we presumably want it to, we can’t strangle it with a 13-member board.And that’s what’s happening … right now.There’s an adage “everyone is talking, but no one is saying a thing.” That is somewhat appropriate in the case of a typical Association meeting with a few notable exceptions.Something is being said, but typically, it’s just about how terrible a job Carlyle did.Frankly, I’m sick of hearing it.In my opinion, with a weak board that provided little to no collective direction and an undermining city administration, Carlyle had no chance. He could have been Warren Buffet, Greg Connell and George Maher all rolled up inside a tidy little three-piece suit and he still would have been bound for the next bus to Omaha.Nobody could have succeeded in this dysfunctional environment. Nobody.But regardless, that chapter is finished. Let it go. The only part of the past that needs addressing is creating a different environment in which the director, staff and board can really work together, while eliminating the ineffectiveness of the current 13-member governing body.Equally concerning at these association meetings, not everyone is talking. In fact, the people who matter the most, the elected board members, are the quietest.They are being dictated to by those without a vote, and when they do venture forth with their own suggestions, as board treasurer Connie Mellott did at the last meeting, they are chided and corrected like misguided schoolchildren.This dog’s tail has gone way beyond metaphorically wagging the body; it’s been cut off and is being used as a whip to punish the poor animal anytime it barks or whimpers.What the Association’s board needs most right now is the support of its investors. Board members seem timid and unwilling to confront the outside forces that are dominating discussion and over-exerting their influence. It’s the deer-in-the-headlines look: they know what to do, but they aren’t quite sure how to do it.These board members need to hear from those who truly make up the Association, its members, that its okay to thank non-voting members for their input and to have them sit down and be quiet as they discusses the organization’s future.It’s time to stop worrying about who’s to blame and who deserves the most praise and credit. It’s time to focus only on one thing: What changes need to be made so the Association can best advance the community it serves.Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express and Glenwood Opinion-Tribune. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com.
