Two Boards Divided
VILLISCA — The Stanton school board has until noon Wednesday to respond to a proposal that would relocate the high school to Villisca and dismissal of their 25-year superintendent.
Villisca’s board made the proposal at a second joint meeting last meeting between the districts regarding a possible whole grade sharing agreement.
“When I look at whole grade sharing, I look at it as a partnership, it isn’t that one school dominates the other or one has more power or decision making,” Villisca High School Principal Lora Top said. “It is an equal partnership. It is no longer going to be the Stanton students and the Villisca students, but it is going to be all of our students.”
Under Villisca’s proposal, by having the high school in Villisca and the middle school in Stanton, each district would maintain its current enrollment numbers. However, if the high school were located in Stanton, Villisca’s enrollment would decrease by 50.
“To me, the high school being here, with each of us sending 70 kids to the other campus is a pretty even partnership,” Villisca board member Tom Williams said. “If we are asked to send 51 kids more your way, that’s pretty uneven. I really have a little trouble stomaching that.”
Other components of Villisca’s proposal included the schools co-hosting football, basketball, softball, baseball and volleyball games. Villisca would exclusively host all golf matches while Stanton would host all track and cross country meets.
Villisca’s proposal also requested each board agree to hire a new superintendent, who would be shared between the two districts.
Denise Taylor, who said she has a student enrolled in both districts, discouraged replacing Stanton Superintendent Judd Ashley.
“I think Mr. Ashley should stay as superintendent. He has proven himself to be extremely responsible and he has managed that school very well,” she said. “I don’t think anyone of us can put Stanton down as far as that school has been run. He’s direct, he’s honest, and he doesn’t mince words, and I like that and I respect him for that.”
Stanton Steering Committee Co-Chair Brett Hultman reiterated that board’s contention the high school should be in Stanton, or as he referred to it in his presentation, the west campus. One benefit he said was its proximity to Red Oak and Southwestern Community College, along with its numerous dual enrollment college courses.
“The west campus is only eight miles away from Southwestern Community College in Red Oak. Students would have an opportunity for face-to-face classes,” he said. “You are going to see online classes are going to require a lot more discipline out of these kids. And with everything these kids have to do and everything we put on them in their daily routine, its pretty tough to have your mind focused on something if you are online on a computer than if you have someone sitting in front of an instructor.”
Another educational benefit to having the high school closer to Red Oak would be access to Red Oak’s technical center.
“The tech center they have there … you will not find a better tech center in the country,” Hultman said. “The possibilities with Red Oak … staff sharing, class sharing, the Tech Center, neither district, if we join together here, can offer what Red Oak might be able to offer us if we go over there.”
He also touted the additional athletic opportunities offered by Red Oak, including wrestling, tennis and bowling, that would be available to students.
“I’m going to talk about athletics and extra curricular activity,” Hultman said. “I want my sons to not only have a great education but also participate in everything they can fit into a day and part of that is athletics. It’s important. Athletics lead to better work and better performance in the classroom. It leads to school pride and community pride.”
Following the two presentations, most of Stanton’s board expressed concern over the one-week time span they had to make a decision.
“This is a big move for us and the timeline is pretty short,” Stanton board president Jeff Magneson said. “I realize you guys have had a lot more time to digest this … but it is relatively new for us. And as you guys know, our steering committee made a recommendation to us not to do anything for next year.”
When pressed for a projected date as to when the whole grade sharing agreement would begin, Villisca Board President Jason Poston once stated the Fall of 2013, but later refused to commit to anything specific.
My answer is I don’t know,” he said. “We don’t know if we are going to get any responses back from our proposals. We have no idea. We might get two answers back. I don’t have the answer to that question because we don’t know what we will be dealing with.”
One Stanton board member expressed concern over that uncertainty.
“I’d like to know what I’m voting for and where my kids are going to go to school next year,” Mark Lindgren said. “Are we going to start sending them next fall, the following fall? That is part of my decision. It is awful fast to swallow all this real quick. A year from now, maybe we would have a little more time to digest this. You guys have had a lot more time to digest this.”
During the public input portion of the meeting, Richard Mullen said he still doesn’t believe Stanton is interested in a true partnership.
“I still see people closed off. I still see people on the Stanton board making demands that are unrealistic,” he said. “That’s not about a partnership and what is the greatest good for the greatest number of people. If things don’t feel right, you can’t start something good on a bad foot.”
Another parent voiced support for locating the high school in Villisca, citing the equity in enrollment.
“Both facilities are equal. So if we come down to both schools are equal, we have very similar curriculum, we have very similar graduation requirements, either school would make a wonderful high school or a wonderful middle school, then I think the only way to look at that is to come down to numbers because you are talking about a sharing agreement,” she said. “Those numbers are what stood out to me. I don’t see how you can do anything other than look at the numbers rather than saying one place would be better than the other based on the football field or a golf course.”
Villisca board member Ray Baker clarified consideration of a whole grade sharing agreement wasn’t precipitated by any financial mismanagement.
“This has nothing to do with how we handled things fiscally. It has to do with what’s going to happen 10 years from now,” Baker said. “We aren’t broke. We aren’t falling apart. We are in perfectly good shape to maintain a district, but we can’t give our kids what they need with the limited students we have in the district, so that’s why we are looking at sharing. We aren’t being forced into anything, we are making good conscious decisions on how this district should look five and 10-years from now.”
Villisca has made proposals to both Stanton and Corning’s school district, each containing the noon, Dec. 7 deadline to respond.
