A troubling trend: Enrollment dropping fast throughout county

RED OAK — There’s one alarming figure all schools in Montgomery County and the surrounding area share in common.

The number doesn’t come from a test. Nor does the number have anything to do with crime, wins, graduation, attendance, losses, salaries, or the quality of food served in the cafeteria.

It’s the one number that is forcing schools into consolidation and whole grade-sharing discussions: Enrollment.

Whether it’s Stanton, Villisca, or Red Oak, enrollment numbers keep dropping year-after-year. The contrast from 10 years ago is stark.

In 2002, Red Oak’s enrollment was 1,335. This year, it is down to 1,212, a drop of more than nine percent. Enrollment topped 1,450 as early as 1996.

Small schools’ drop can be even more extreme.

In 2002, Villisca’s enrollment was 441. Today, it’s down to 364, or 18 percent.

“The main thing I feel is jobs and job opportunities,” Villisca Superintendent Willie Stone said of the drop. “All the surrounding communities have had some pretty big companies close in the last 5-10 years which provided a good share of jobs for everybody. People have to go where there are jobs.”

Even Stanton, buoyed by an influx of open enrollment students, is down 20 percent, at 248 today compared to 310 in 2002.

With the drop in students is a corresponding drop in revenue. This year, the school district’s receive $5,883 per student enrolled.

Stanton had 21 more students a year ago, which would have entitled them to $123,543 additional state revenue. Red Oak’s dropped only four students, costing them $23,532.

Villisca’s enrollment actually increased by two students over last year, giving them an extra $11,766.

“When you lose enrollment, you don’t have any mechanism to make up for the lost revenue,” Red Oak Superintendent Terry Schmidt said. “You can't go to the community and ask them to make it up and the state isn't going to make it up. There is no way to recoup that without making substantial changes to the organization.”

Action/Reaction

As a result of the drops in enrollment, schools have had to take several cost saving measures from reducing staff, eliminating bus routes and classes, even sharing administration and staff.

Stone is Villisca and Corning’s superintendent. Red Oak shares a business manager with Stanton and a transportation director with Villisca.

But beyond superintendents, business managers, and even sporting teams, the biggest thing schools are sharing are actual grades.

Villisca is in the midst of whole grade sharing discussions with Stanton and Corning and the reason for it is simple.

“Gradual decline in enrollment is the biggest issue,” Stone said.

Some schools have consolidated, such as Nishna Valley and Malvern, which formed the East Mills School District.

With consolidation, the two districts become one, while with whole grade sharing, the districts maintain separate identities with their own school boards and finances, responsible for managing the grades under their supervision.

When Schmidt came to Red Oak, he was forced to make drastic cuts, dropping the number of teachers from 113 to as low as 97. While the number is back up to about 100 this year, penny-pinching is still the norm.

“No position here gets automatically filled unless it gets closely scrutinized,” he said.

And no cost savings is too small. Last year, the district closed the school and turned off the utilities during Christmas break.

Athletic teams had to practice at the local YMCA, but the district saved about $18,000.

“That’s half a beginning teacher’s yearly salary,” Schmidt said.  

Open Enrollment

One dynamic working in favor, or against school districts is open enrollment.

As mandated by Iowa law, parents can enroll their child in any public school system, and with the $5,883 in state funding accompanying the student, it can greatly affect a district’s finances.

When he was hired by the Red Oak school board, Schmidt said part of his mandate was to stop the bleeding of open enrollment.

In 2005, 100 students opted out of Red Oak, while only 21 came to the district, costing the school over $400,000 in funding.

“Whenever I came here we were getting smoked by our competitors, because once kids leave for kindergarten, first, or second grade, they aren't coming back,” Schmidt said. “I spent many nights calling people who were choosing to leave Red Oak. Not to change their mind but to introduce myself and ask them why they were leaving. I wanted to learn what was causing them to leave.”

Schmidt said the reasons varied, including wanting smaller class sizes, or better athletic programs. But the most common reason, he said, was the parents simply remembered bad experiences when they were in the Red Oak district.

“I would say 25 percent easily of all those people I talked to did not have a good experience when they went to school in Red Oak and when they had kids, they didn’t want them going to Red Oak.”

By listening to the concerns and making changes where he could, Schmidt has seemingly reversed the trend. The margin of difference between students enrolling out and enrolling into the district has dropped each year he has been superintendent, down to 28 this year.

He also believes the 4-year-old preschool program, which is now in its third year and is enrolled to its maximum of 80 students will help continue to stop the open enrollment exodus.

“They are going to preschool together. They are already involved with the district and the district family,” he said.

This year, 37 students enrolled out of Villisca while only seven open enrolled into the district. The 30-student difference cost the district more than $176,000.

“I never argue with a parent because I think it is a parent’s right to take their kids where they want to go. The state has made it the parent’s right,” Stone said of open enrollment. “It is best for parents to take their kids where they think they will get the best education. Do I think it is best for schools? That I don’t know.”

The Stanton school district sits squarely on the other side of the spectrum, with 68 students enrolling in this year and 15 enrolling out, the most in more than 10 years.

However, the 53-student difference, and the accompanying $311,000 in funding, is essential, representing more than 21 percent of the total enrollment.

That number has been as high as 25 percent in 2009.

Stanton Superintendent Judd Ashley said quality fine arts programs, strong discipline, and high academic performance and expectations are all reasons parents cited for choosing Stanton.

“I think Stanton prepares students fairly well for what lies ahead after graduation, whether it be college, the workforce, vocational school or the armed services,” Ashley said.

Taking families on tours of the Stanton facility for more than 25 years as superintendent, Ashley said parent’s concerns are safety, and then academic performance.

“Our philosophy is lets let our results speak for themselves in terms of a zero dropout rate, 90 plus percent going to post secondary education, with about 40 percent plus of those who go on actually get a degree,” Ashley said.  “I tell my staff, you come to school each and every day and give 100 percent and do the best for each student, and let the results speak for themselves.”

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here