Time to correct a mistake on the Packard house

An editor told me years ago that the surest way to confirm readership was to make a mistake.   
Write an opinion people disagree with and they may or may not respond.  
But, she said, print something verifiably incorrect—a misspelled name or transposed basketball score—and they will let you know.  
This is good.  We want to know.  
Apparently I erred in a recent column on Jason Packard, making reference to his eight-sided house.  
A number of members of the Montgomery County Historical Society commented.  
The house was built with six sides, not eight. MCHC Director Dave McFarland tells me has a photograph showing this to be the case.  
So I apologize and issue the correction. The house was a hexagon, not an octagon.  With that taken care of, those of you who own a copy of Merritt’s History of Montgomery County may want to turn to page 117 and make a similar correction.  
Merritt, among other things, was a farmer, newspaper publisher, historian, elected official, minister, and postmaster.  
He was surely among our most distinguished citizens.  
A Montgomery County resident since 1857, he agreed to write the history of this county.  His work, published in 1906, is generally considered a reliable reference.
Merritt knew Packard, worked with him, found the man so interesting he devoted an entire chapter to him.  
He was also intrigued by the house Jason and Cornelia designed and built, and describes it in some detail.
 Merritt was there. He could count.  He knew what an octagon was.  He printed a photograph of the house.   
And yet, assuming today’s historians are right, Merritt was wrong. That being the case I’ll bet he got an earful, and once his books were published there wasn’t an effective way to set the record straight.         
 All this gives me an excuse to say a word about Wikipedia, an on-line reference used extensively by students and researchers and which, like so many other sources, is accepted as gospel.  
Wikepedia recently carried biographical material on Captain Sir Alan Mcilwraith of the British Army.  
Mcilwraith was credited with heroism in combat by risking his own life to protect his men, for which he was awarded the DSO.  
The bio was accompanied by a photograph of the gallant Captain Sir Mcilwraith in full uniform.  
This material was accepted as fact until it was pointed out to Wikepedia staff that it was made up by a certain Alan Mcilwraith, a young computer whiz and customer service representative for Dell.  
The photograph was his, but not the uniform.     
Another Wikipedia entry that was eventually corrected stated that the philosopher Plato was “an ancient Hawaiian weather man and surfer.”     
So understand that some of the things you read, whether in the newspaper, Wikepedia, or history books, are not necessarily factual.  
But this column wants to get it right, so when we don’t let us know.    
Roy Marshall is a local historian and columnist for the Red Oak Express. He can be contacted at news@redoakexpress.com
 

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here