The Time Capsule | Roy Marshall
Finding a local tenderloin to nominate for the Iowa Pork Producers Association (IPPA) annual contest seemed easy enough. This county produces tons of pork, has a lot of places that make the sandwich, and I’m sure the guy I talked to at the IPPA office was anxious for our opinion.
I say “our” opinion, as an early issue was my wife. Her background in restaurants began in high school. In the years since, she worked in half a dozen others.
Although I didn’t ask, she told me how this was going to be done. She laid out a methodical approach, starting with a list of establishments and another of judging criteria. The first, ranging from taverns to the hospital cafeteria, was lengthy. We cut it by eliminating those that either didn’t serve the tenderloin or had the boxed and frozen variety. The fresh loin was to be pounded, dipped and breaded in the kitchen with their recipe.
She modeled our judging standard on the Kansas City Barbecue Society’s method, which gives points for appearance, taste and tenderness. I took the course a few years ago and had reservations, plus there was the matter of tenderness, which hardly seemed applicable with a tenderized tenderloin. She replaced “tenderness” with the subjective combination of “value” and “ambiance.” A max of nine points would be awarded in each of three categories. We’d score independently, without discussion, and compare later.
The column about doing this brought a couple of suggestions from readers. I also heard from two restaurant managers who invited me to meet and have a loin on the house. This sounded good. I was overruled. Wife was firm; we’d go down the list, unannounced during meal time. No freebies, no special consideration.
During the 90s, while living in Des Moines, I made the rounds. The state fair was a starting point. The Machine Shed in Urbandale had a good one, as did a diner on Army Post. Another was a place called B&B Grocery on East 6th south of the Capital. B&B was well-located for me, their price was good, and they’ve won an IPPA best-in-state award.
Des Moines area newspapers have given B&B a lot of ink, but to my taste the delis at Red Oak’s Hy-Vee and Villisca’s grocery serve a tenderloin just as good. Also on our list were a couple of taverns, a diner and restaurants. We were looking for a bit of crunch from lightly seasoned breading and pork that was done but not dry. I wanted a fresh bun, generous overlap and the usual condiments.
We haven’t had a bad one, but there were disappointments. The first place served me one that had overlap only because the loin wasn’t centered on the bun. When adjusted it barely covered. This was probably not typical—my wife’s exceeded the bun on both sides—but I gave mine only a five for appearance.
We hit a place near Christmas that was busier than our waitress could handle. She was buried in traffic, my order went to someone else and by the time it was straightened out the mood was gone. Another spot lost a point because wife was sure hers was done in oil that was a bit off-taste.
Some places were no doubt better than they were the day we were there, but we judged on what we got.
Nine points per category means a perfect score of twenty-seven, and so far two have rated that high on both scorecards. There are a couple of loins remaining, so we could have more. I’m afraid multiple nominations from the same source would not be persuasive, so may return for another comparison.
The IPPA will begin this year’s judging cycle in May, with the winner announced in October. I’ll submit one from this county and hope it does better than my expense account, which was dead on arrival.
Roy Marshall is a local historian and columnist for the Red Oak Express. He can be contacted at news@redoakexpress.com.
