The Time Capsule | Roy Marshall
The commercial has a man wired to a polygraph. His wife, a stern-looking sort, asks if he thinks her sister is prettier. Fred Harris, a former southwest Iowa resident, could have been asked that question by each of seven sisters.
He married all of them. One at a time. Legally.
My wife was doubtful of the story, so I retrieved the newspaper item and the announcement of his seventh and final wedding to the seventh and final sister.
Harris was born in New York in 1831. As a young man he moved west. In Chicago he found work driving a horse-drawn taxi, or hack. A few miles to the north was Milwaukee, home of Peter Yost. Yost, captain of a Great Lakes freight vessel, was the father of seven daughters. The eldest was, according to the article, married to Harris — probably in the early 1850s. She died young, and Harris married one of her sisters. Later he married another, and another.
The 1921 wedding announcement is short on specifics, but discloses that over the years Harris was often widowed. Some of the sisters lost their first husband. He’d marry one, then a few years later another. The last five were, at the time he married them, widows.
Harris was 90 when he proposed marriage to Mrs. Gustave Yost Eidelmann. She was the youngest sister, 78 years of age and apparently unconcerned that none of her sisters had survived the experience. The newlyweds bought a small home and orchard in rural Cass County, settling in, the paper said, “to enjoy their final years.”
The story was carried in The New York World on Sept. 29, 1921.
My wife questions the authenticity of anything published in that newspaper. The New York World, under the leadership of Joseph Pulitzer and later his son, was a powerful national voice of the Democratic Party. The World sold papers and viewpoints with sensationalism, bias, exaggerations and lies. Their circulation opponent, The New York Journal, owned by William Randolph Hearst – also a political activist – was just as bad. Both editors, favoring a new regime in Cuba, used their newspapers to arouse the public with slanted stories and created an atmosphere that contributed to the 1898 declaration of war against Spain. We got Gitmo; the revolutionaries got Cuba.
To further advance circulation, The World and The Journal featured stories of gruesome crime and lurid sex. On slow days, their reporters and correspondents were not above manufacturing items designed to sell.
Did they fabricate or exaggerate the Harris story, placing the bride and groom in far-away southwest Iowa, thereby making it unlikely that anyone would check?
I don’t know. My wife, the skeptic, went through census records and found neither Harris nor his wife. This is meaningless, though, as they were said to have arrived a year after the 1920 count and, at their ages, might have been gone by 1930. Neither could she locate an obituary, but the name is so common this is not conclusive either.
The New York World passed the story off as true, so take your choice.
Roy Marshall is a local historian and columnist for the Red Oak Express. Contact him at news@redoakexpress.com.
