The Time Capsule | Roy Marshall
The recipe that mom’s favorite cousin, Vernon Slane, referred to as “Christmas Puddin’” wasn’t pudding at all. It was a dense, dark liqueur that called for 29 black walnuts, which were to be “picked from the tree on June 23.” Vernon, apparently a poet, lived in Missouri, and I’d guess their growing season is a week or so ahead of ours. The window of opportunity is no doubt more than just a day, so if anyone wants to try making a batch, the walnuts in this area are probably still okay.
My memory of Slane was jogged by the latest issue of Nebraskaland magazine, which describes how to make green walnut liqueur, known in Italy as “nocino.” Nebraskaland’s version has 25 green walnuts (how Vernon settled on 29 I have no idea), sugar, cloves, star anise and a liter of vodka. I’m sure it’s fine, a safer bet than Vernon’s, but I thought it odd that Nebraskaland does not specify which kind of walnut and their photo shows the English variety. I doubt Vernon ever saw a California-grown English walnut.
Mom never made it, but years ago she asked him to write down the recipe he’d been using, so it was said, as far back as Prohibition.
With it and a bucket I set out on June 23 to pick 29 walnuts. They were easy enough, coming from the same trees I’d tapped for sap to boil into black walnut syrup. Next step was to cut them into quarters. The shells are soft at this stage and a chef’s knife worked well. The Nebraskaland recipe has all ingredients added to a glass jar, stored in a dark place and stirred occasionally for 40 days, then strained. Their instructions say it can be used immediately or allowed to mellow for a couple of months.
Vernon did his differently. His recipe puts the cut-up walnuts (black, not English, hulls included), into a gallon jar. Added are two cinnamon sticks (he didn’t use star anise or cloves), the grated rind of a lemon and one quart of ’shine. I wish the old boy was still around to make the lightning, but he’s not so I substituted Everclear. The jug was capped and put in a dark corner of the basement. After three months the contents are to be strained, walnuts “fed to the hogs” and the liquid, Vernon wrote, “sweetened with syrup, shaked up good and put away til Christmas unless Thanks Giving gets here sooner.”
We appreciate Vernon’s humor, and his hogs were probably a jolly bunch, but I wish he’d told us what he meant by “sweetened with syrup.” Simple syrup? He made sorghum syrup; might he have used it? Whatever the sweetener, how much? Nebraskaland’s recipe called for 2 ½ cups of sugar, so in late September I’ll either add that or honey.
Vernon brought out his puddin’ at family events. Relatives recall that a sip or two was an eye-opener and it was great drizzled on ice cream and strawberries. It was off-limits to kids, though, so I don’t know.
Hopefully the jug in the basement is worth the effort. I’ll test it on Christmas, unless Thanksgiving gets here sooner. If we have an adventuresome reader who wants a sample, stop by about that time. Wife says the stuff is out of her league, and I’m reluctant to try it alone.
Roy Marshall is a local historian and columnist for the Red Oak Express. He can be contacted at news@redoakexpress.com.
