The Time Capsule: Display needed to commemorate orphanage

There are hundreds of stories associated with the orphanage that once operated in Montgomery County, and some took place long after the last child was sent away.  
One has to do with three brothers who left an unusual will; a will that led to an acrimonious feud between two communities.        
According to news articles published in 1961 and ‘62, three Nelson brothers spent their lives farming in the Bethesda area.  (Records show orphans once living in the home with similar names, but there were a lot of Nelsons and I can’t say whether there was a connection.) Regardless, the Nelsons of Bethesda grew old with a fondness for the orphanage—and a plan. They wanted the buildings, only about 20 years old when vacated, re-opened as a home for the elderly.  
They apparently worked hard, lived frugally, amassed a fortune, and were willing to spend a good share of it to make the retirement home a reality.  
A joint will was prepared. Several beneficiaries were named, one being the Bethesda Lutheran Church. The key provision was a stipulation that about $150,000 be set aside for the home, money that would go to any “Lutheran organization” that agreed to use the buildings for the purpose the brothers had in mind. There had to be a commitment within five years of the death of the last brother; if not, the money was to be divided among the initially named beneficiaries.
The last brother died in 1959.  Disbursements were made, with $150,000 held in escrow. As the orphanage had been located a mile from Stanton, that community had a particular interest. With the five-year period ticking down, the Good Samaritan Society showed an interest. Their representatives inspected the buildings, found them satisfactory, announced their intentions, and the home seemed assured.  
Then an objection was filed. A representative of the Bethesda Church contended  Good Samaritan was not a “Lutheran organization” as contemplated in the will, citing Good Sam’s background with the Augustana branch rather than Evangelical. Stanton’s group protested, arguing Bethesda had gotten one cut of the estate and just wanted another.  The Nelson brothers, it was pointed out, desired exactly what Good Sam was proposing to do. Splitting hairs on just how “Lutheran” the organization was amounted—in the opinion of some—to self-serving pettiness.   
Bethesda stood firm, and the case headed for court. When subpoenas were served on Good Sam executives, they decided the legal fees and negative publicity would be too much. They withdrew the claim and looked for another site. Orphanage buildings continued to decay and were eventually razed.       
Today, the only reminder of what once was is a sign on M63.  I’ve often thought this is a shame.  For nearly 60 years the place was a refuge, a home for children in need, an example of how compassionate people dealt with the issue prior to government programs and a shift to foster care.  
With a dorm for 30 girls, another for 30 boys, a school, 240 acres of farmland, a 15-acre garden, orchard, dairy herd, flock of 900 chickens, draft horses and more, youngsters learned to work, accept responsibility, and many went on to successful lives. The orphanage, which opened a few years after the first “Orphan Train” pulled out of New York City, is undeniably of historic importance. But, for reasons I fail to understand, nearly 80 years have passed since it closed and there still is not a suitable museum display.   
I brought this up at a recent board meeting at Stanton’s History Center, and received an appropriate answer: put together a plan for the display, include a feasible method of covering the cost, and they’ll provide the space and help in any way practical. This is fair and can be done. I have reason to believe funding will not be a problem. The history center has scrapbooks containing enough photographs and records for a display.
I’m sure, though, that more exist and the larger the selection to choose from the better the final exhibit. I’m asking readers who have orphanage memorabilia--pictures, letters, whatever—to let me know. My number is in the Stanton phone book.   
 

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here