Talking Trash: Explaining the benefits of mandatory garbage

Editor’s Note: This will be the first in a series of articles regarding waste collection in Red Oak.

No one likes the word “mandatory,” myself included. So it’s no wonder that it seems like few people are interested in exploring “mandatory garbage pickup” for the City of Red Oak.  But what if I told you “mandatory garbage” would actually cost you less and give you more? Would you be interested in at least considering the idea?

I must admit, when the “mandatory garbage collection” idea was brought up a few years ago at a City Council meeting, I had the same gut reaction I think a lot of people have: “Seriously?” I remember thinking it was just a way for the City—or someone—to make more money off taxpayers. Well, I couldn’t have been more mistaken. But I have only come to this conclusion through extensive research, the “meat” of which I would like to share.

What does “mandatory garbage collection” really mean? Essentially, it means you pay for your waste to be collected every month—usually on a utility bill, like water or electricity. What “mandatory garbage collection” doesn’t mean is you HAVE to put your trash out to be picked up. But it’s true that you don’t choose your garbage hauler—the City does that when they contract with a company. But keep in mind, you don’t choose your water or electric company either.

One of the biggest “issues” with mandatory garbage collection is it has the potential to put local companies out of business. The City calls for bids for the hauling contract and the lowest bidder, of course, usually wins. Who is usually the lowest bidder for such contracts? Big companies that have the resources to offer lower prices, ala Walmart or Sam’s Club—or in this case, Iowa Waste Systems, for example.  But who says the City couldn’t implement a stipulation that the hauling contract must go to a LOCAL company? That would eradicate the “local business will lose” argument. And really, for the City of Red Oak, the current “competition” consists of just two local companies—Batten Sanitation located in Red Oak and Town and Country Sanitation located in Griswold.

So how does mandatory garbage actually work? Well…very much the same that our current “mandatory recycling” program works…Yes, we have that in Red Oak.  

All of us pay $1.25/month for recycling. You can find this charge on your water bill—just look for “RC” which stands for “recycling.” This is the word “mandatory” in action. Not so scary, huh?

So the City has a contract with Batten Sanitation to “handle” our recyclables—by providing three roll-off containers behind Fareway-- for $3,200/month. That money comes from what the City collects from our water bills. Batten’s job is to keep those bins empty enough for us to be able to deposit our recyclables day or night.

Do you have to use the roll-off containers behind Fareway to deposit your recyclables? No, but you might as well…you’re paying for it!

But there is a major problem with our current “waste management” system that, by making trash pick up “mandatory”, could easily be solved.

Let’s say you don’t have a place out in the country to burn your trash or you’re not super keen on the idea of illegally dumping your rubbish in a ditch. You pay for garbage collection every month so you don’t have the nuisance officer knocking on your door with a clean-up ticket as he walks through a rat’s nest among the piled up bags. You have a choice of two haulers: You can either pay around $19/month for Batten or $18.50/month for Town and Country to pick up your trash every week.

But what if you don’t even come close to filling your allotted three 33-gallon containers because you recycle nearly half of what your “trash” would be (according to statistics, more than 40 percent of the waste we generate is recyclable and should not go into the landfill.)

Do either of those companies—Batten or Town and Country—offer a discount to those who recycle and have very little that they send to the landfill? No, they don’t. You pay your monthly fee whether you use it to capacity or not.

No wonder people put their garbage in with others’—something local haulers regularly fight—even in court! (something that “mandatory garbage” would take care of, as well.)

And here’s where the overwhelming benefit of having “mandatory garbage” really shines. I will use the town of Spencer, Iowa as an example.

Spencer, population around 10,000, requiress “mandatory garbage pickup” for its residents. There is one hauler that handles the whole city. Every month, electricity users pay a certain amount on their bill for this service. What do they get for this charge? They get garbage collection and curbside recycling pickup every other week.

“This must be expensive,” you might be thinking — because there is a commonly held belief that curbside recycling is expensive. Well…How much do Spencer residents pay for this? The charge just went up to $13/month. Yes, the charge was just raised from around $11 to just $13 each month for trash collection and curbside recycling.

That’s less than either of our two local haulers charge and that’s way more service.

How can they do this? The answer is simple, and it is the same answer as to how Batten can manage three roll off containers of recyclables: everyone is paying into the system!

So there is enough money to work with to provide these great and helpful services to residents. And it’s not only good for residents, it’s good for the whole community: making neighborhoods cleaner, keeping ditches and waterways cleaner, keeping recyclables out of the landfill and the City even makes some money from selling these valuable materials to companies who use them to make “post-consumer waste” products.

It’s a winning situation for everyone involved. And that’s how it could be in Red Oak.

I hope you feel like you understand what mandatory garbage collection is really about and I hope you will feel compelled to contact your City Council member—just go to the City website: http://www.redoakiowa.com/ashadebetter/Content.aspx?ContentId=80 to let him know how you feel about it. Or call City Administrator Brad Wright at 712-623-6510. Talk to your garbage hauler, too.

If everyone pays in a little bit into the system, the system can offer a whole lot more to everyone. After considering what mandatory garbage collection would really mean for us, doesn’t it seem like a good idea?

Submitted by,
Jennifer Horner
Red Oak

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here