Still Living With a Mystery
VILLISCA - Maybe it was the ex-business partner, F.F. Jones, enacting revenge by hiring a stockyard worker to kill his biggest competitor.
Maybe it was the perverted preacher who was fond of window peeping on young girls undressing.
Maybe it was the Missouri man who later killed his mother and grandmother in a similar manner.
Or maybe it was just a serial killer who was never captured or suspected in the grisly murders.
One hundred years have passed since the Josiah Moore family and two visiting girls were brutally killed in their sleep, but debate over who was wielding the ax early in the morning June 10, 1912, continued throughout the weekend in Montgomery County.
Kelly and Tammy Rundle and the man they believe knows more about the ax murders than anyone else, Dr. Edgar Epperly, were in Red Oak during the weekend to talk about Iowa's largest mass murder which remains unsolved today.
The Rundles, a husband/wife filmmaking team whose list of credits include “Country School: One Room, One Nation,” “Lost Nation: The Ioway” and their first documentary, “Villisca: Living With a Mystery,” premiered their newest project, “Axman” at the Montgomery County History Center. “Axman” is a tribute to and portrayal of Epperly, who has studied and investigated the murders since he was a college student in 1955.
“It became a hobby or something I could do on my free time,” Epperly said after the showing of “Axman” Sunday afternoon. “Eventually, it became an event that filled my life.”
The short documentary “Axman” and full-feature length “Villisca: Living With a Mystery” were first shown Saturday night to History Center members only, followed by a screening Sunday to the general public. A question and answer session with the filmmakers and college professor turned historian followed the documentaries.
Most of the audience's questions focused on the suspects, a subject even the Rundles and Epperly couldn't agree on.
“It's the one thing Ed's wrong about,” Kelly said, smiling.
Henry Lee Moore
In their movie “Villisca: Living With a Mystery,” the Rundles theorize the murders were the work of a serial killer, Henry Lee Moore (no relation to Josiah Moore.)
Henry Lee Moore was arrested a few months after the Villisca murders in Columbia, Mo., for killing his mother and grandmother with an ax.
Moore confessed to the two killings and would be sentenced to life in prison. He told investigators he had seen worse crime scenes than this one and worked for the railroad at the time of the murders, which could have placed him in Villisca at the time of the murders.
He had also been released from prison in 1911 in Colorado, just before a string of similar ax murders started occurring in the Midwest, including ones in Colorado, Kansas and Illinois in addition the one in Villisca.
“We can't say for certain it was Henry Moore but based on what we did with the forensic people, he at least represents the type of individual we believe committed the crime,” Kelly Rundle said.
Epperly disagreed.
“The reason I don't agree with it is the Iowa Attorney General's Office investigated him at the time of the murder and I haven't been able to find what they found in that investigation but they dismissed him as a suspect,” Epperly said. “So I think they found something. I'm guessing it was employment records of some time.”
Epperly does agree with one aspect of the Rundle's theory: that whomever was responsible for the murders in Villisca was guilty of similar crimes elsewhere.
“When I read the newspapers, you just know it is the same person doing all those murders,” he said. “They are similar. It just seems so obvious this is a serial killer going from one place to another. I don't agree its Henry Lee Moore, but its somebody.”
Rev. George Kelly
The only person actually charged in the murders was the diminutive traveling Presby-terian preacher, George Kelly.
After a jury in the first trial failed to reach a verdict, Kelly was acquitted in the second trial, but Epperly still isn't entirely convinced of his innocence.
“He was always peeking in windows. He would go to great lengths to see a young girl without any clothes on … which doesn't make him absolutely unusual,” Epperly said. “[But] when you couple that with the young girl downstairs who was posed provocatively and the windows were closed carefully and the killer wanted time and privacy, you start to think he might have done it.”
Epperly believes a bloodied shirt belonging to Kelly and testimony the preacher was discussing the murders on a train the following day before the murders were discovered further incriminate him.
However, he admits even that isn't enough to convince him.
“As I put it, good old wishy-washy Charlie Brown,” Epperly said. “It's Kelly one day, serial killer the next. What I would really love to prove is find Kelly in one of those towns where the other murders happened.”
“Or Henry,” Kelly interrupted.
“Yes, or Henry,” Epperly conceded.
F.F. Jones
If there is one thing Epperly is certain about, it's the innocence of F.F. Jones, a prominent Villisca businessman and rival of the Moores.
“I'm 110 percent certain it's not Jones,” Epperly said “The man offered as the killer by Wilkerson, can definitely prove he was in Montgomery, Ill., at the time of the murders.”
Epperly was referring to William “Blackie” Mansfield, who was arrested by Detective James Wilkerson for the murders. Wilkerson contended Jones hired Mansfield to kill Moore, who had opened a competing hardware/implement store in Villisca.
Mansfield appeared before a grand jury investigating the murders, but payroll records indicated he wasn't in Villisca at the time of the murders.
Jones, a state senator, would file a $60,000 slander suit against Wilkerson, but lost that case in 1917. In many people's minds, he remained a suspect for several years later.
Rundle said Villisca residents were divided between the Presbyterians who believed Jones was guilty and the Methodists who felt Rev. Kelly was the murderer.
“Our film isn't about the murders. It's about everything that happened because of the murders,” Rundle said. “We remember these victims, and not just those who died, but those who were falsely accused. There were many people who were negatively impacted by this.”
The Crime
Epperly and the Rundles also answered specific questions about the crime, including what evidence remained (just the ax), if they believed the killer hid in waiting in the closets and why the parents didn't wake up in time.
Epperly recalled interviewing a Montgomery County prosecutor who said no matter how hard he tried, he couldn't walk up the stairs into the Moore's bedroom without making the stairs creak.
However, Epperly said with two girls visiting the Moores that night, he doesn't believe the creaking stairs would have caused much alarm.
“If I’m lying in bed and I have two visiting kids downstairs and I hear light steps on the stairs, it never occurs to me to think ‘I wonder if that is an axe murderer coming to kill me,’” Epperly said. “I say ‘oh oh, those kids can't go to sleep, they are nervous and I have to get work at 7 in the morning and its midnight already. Maybe if I lay perfectly still and maybe if I don't sit up, maybe they will come up and look and see that everything is okay and go back.’ If I were creating a scenario in fiction, that's how I would paint it.”
Epperly added he had no difficulty believing the children never awoke.
“Children sleep the sleep of the just,” he said. “They go to bed and they sleep. They don't assume any responsibility for monitoring the house when they go to sleep.”
Rundle pointed out the house was small for six people to live in, and as such, the closets were too filled for anyone to be hiding in, waiting for everyone to go to sleep.
“It just isn't something that makes any common sense,” Rundle said. “The safe thing to do is to enter the home during that time people are sleeping very deeply and commit the crime when they are in that sleep.”
100 Years Later
At the actual house, owner Martha Lin brought in re-enactors who conducted a memorial service and helped with tours of the home.
Some of the re-enactors played parts of key suspects, such as F.F. Jones and Rev. Kelly.
About 50 people attended Saturday night’s members-only screening at the history center and 50 more were there Sunday, many from out of town.
“It’s an event that still captures our attention, 100 years later, and will probably still capture our attention 100 years from now,” Rundle said.
