Sign ordinance changes passed despite protests

RED OAK — Despite a petition containing hundreds of names and the protests of several citizens at its last meeting, Red Oak’s City Council voted 3-2 to approve changes to its existing sign ordinance.

After first approving the ordinance in 2010, the City Council first began looking at amendments to it earlier this year, which would grandfather in several non-conforming signs.

However, those amendments didn’t include any sign taller than eight feet, prompting an initial petition of 94 names, and postponing any changes to it.

In addition to a second petition containing nearly 300 signatures, several local residents and business owners attend the April 4 meeting, urging the Council to reconsider requiring monument signs.

“You just cannot see these signs when they are on the ground,” said Bryce Van Houghton, owner of Van Houghton Electric. “You need to keep them up in the air so you can see them. Red Oak is not what you would call real thriving, so we need all the help we can get. Anytime we can attract a new … customer into town, it benefits all of us.”

Van Houghton and Tom Youngberg organized the petition drives, and both own businesses on Oak street with pole signs.

“I think everybody admits these signs aren’t for the betterment of Red Oak,” Youngberg said. “Some signs look better than others. These ground level signs are a hazard because you can’t see around them.”

Chris Dovel, owner of three businesses in town, including one on Broadway, said monument signs simply aren’t visible.

“These ground level signs ... this is not the way to go,” Dovel said. “You can’t see them, you come up on them, and you are by the business before you even know you are there.”

Steve Fenn said while he doesn’t own a business, he opposes the sign ordinance  on the principle that a select few get to determine what is and is not acceptable and appealing.

“This is somebody else’s idea that these smaller signs … are going to beautify Broadway,” Fenn said. “Why do you think you can take one person’s idea what is pretty for the city and make it for everybody. It is everybody’s city.”

After the citizen comment portion of the meeting, the Council further discussed the amendments to the existing ordinance.  

The newest version allows businesses to keep their current signs, unless they are located on Senate, Broadway or Commerce Drive. All signs more than eight feet on those streets would still be illegal.

But everywhere else, the current signs can remain. However, once they need repairs that cost more than 50 percent of replacement cost, they must be replaced with a monument sign.

Councilman Ivan Craig disagreed with that requirement.

“I think … we are leading people astray,” Craig said. If we are saying it is okay to keep that sign until you have to do repairs that may cost 50 percent more, then you have to come back and follow these guidelines. I disagree with that. I think we aren’t doing our job if we say it is okay until you have to put money into it, and then we are going to force you to do something you don’t want to do.”

Councilman Larry Brandstetter sees it more as a compromise.

“Basically, we are saying the people off Broadway, Senate and Commerce are able to keep their signs. They can keep it as long as it stays there,” he said.  “They can keep it as long as they want to as long as they continue to repair it or keep it in shape and that sort of thing.”

But Craig pointed out that may not always be true.

“But if somebody happens to screw up and you get a drunk driver that happens to pull over and hits his sign and knocks it over,” Craig said. “That is one of those situations that it is more than 50 percent.”
When the matter came to a vote, Craig and Roger Waggener voted no, while Brandstetter, Tom Pratt and Mark Gregg voted yes.
Pratt, who had be an ardent opponent of the ordinance, said after the meeting he thought the changes were acceptable to all parties.

“I thought, to me, this was a pretty good compromise. I thought we negotiated that thing down to where it originally intended,” he said.
Pratt, who manages Orscheln Farm and Home, with a large pole sign out front that is now allowed under the new amendments, said he would have voted for the changes regardless of how it affected his business.

“I think monument signs look beautiful. It really sets things apart,” he said. “I’ve been here 25 years, and I still have people call me asking where is your location, so I wonder how good the sign works anyway.”

He said while it would have been his preference to grandfather in all signs, he didn’t feel like there was support on the Council for it, and that these changes made most of the people happy.

“The majority of the people who complained to me are happy with it, so if I satisfied the majority, that’s pretty good,” Pratt said.
Youngberg said after the meeting he is not part of that majority, while questioning the accuracy of that assertion.

“I feel they are legal at one time, how can you make them illegal now,” he said. “And everyone I have talked to wants to know the same thing.”

At the April 4 meeting, the Council approved the first reading. A second and third reading will have to be approved before the ordinance is voted into affect.

Also at the meeting, the Council:

— Listened to a request from Perry White to renew efforts to clean up Red Oak. White largely read from a letter to the editor printed in today’s Red Oak Express, in which he stated the Council “dropped the ball” in cleaning up the city. He said he is also frustrated with people dumping trash in his dumpsters, while urging the Council to revisit the issue.

—  Approved a settlement agreement with Southwest Iowa Liquor Shop for selling tobacco to a minor. Under the agreement, Southwest Iowa Liquor agrees to pay a $300 fine.

— Agreed to pursue a contract with Green Tree Company for temporary relocation of the city brush pile. City Administrator Brad Wright said the relocation is necessary due to security concerns associated with the ongoing construction of the wastewater treatment plant near the current brush pile. Under the contract, which will be voted on at the April 19 council meeting, Green Tree would receive $500 a month from the city.

— Awarded a $91,321.78 contract to Carley Construction for paving of the Red Oak Recreational Trail.

— Selected Nutri-Ject Systems Inc., as a contractor to clean out two digester tanks and the sludge storage tank as part of the ongoing rehabilitation project at the wastewater treatment plant. 

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here