Sidewalk discussion ends with split vote
The Red Oak City Council voted to take no action on sidewalk replacement at 110 E. Market St.
Following the recent change to a city ordinance eliminating the city’s liability in the case of injury on an ill-maintained sidewalk, the subject of a sidewalk replacement at the Market Street property owned by Clayton Adams was brought before the council by Councilman Roger Waggoner, who said he’d been getting calls from concerned citizens about the sidewalk.
“They tell me, if the council lets this slide by, what’s to say that in another month or two, someone will come before the council asking to have their sidewalk taken out. If we don’t enforce it, I think we’re opening up a big can of worms,” advised Waggoner.
Adams was in attendance at the council meeting, and said he had not replaced the sidewalk, not because of monetary issues, but over safety concerns.
“The drive lane of that building is owned by Burlington Northern. There’s a lot of traffic we can’t control. My fear is, if we replace that sidewalk, and a kid runs out into the blind spot, I truly believe it’s a safety concern. That Burlington Northern Alleyway is on the south side of the building, and based on my building’s location, it’s going to create a blind spot when and if that sidewalk is replaced, ” Adams said.
Adams added he was completely fine with replacing the sidewalk, and understood Waggoner’s concerns, but he hoped the council weighed the safety concerns.
“Saying it’s a rule doesn’t define whether or not it should be there. I think this is a mitigating circumstance that should be taken into consideration in a decision to replace the sidewalk,” Adams commented.
Wright said it was the council’s decision whether or not to require replacement of the sidewalk, based on city code, if they felt it needed to be replaced.
Council member Scott Keith said it was his feeling that the council would have difficulty enforcing other sidewalk replacements if they failed to enforce action on this replacement. Adams again questioned action based on a rule, rather than circumstances.
“If someone comes into the council meeting and has a valid reason for their need to remove a sidewalk, it allows for determinations on a case-by-case basis, rather than a blanket rule. I don’t want to have someone injured on a new sidewalk over a rule,” commented Adams.
Waggoner made a motion to require a replacement of the sidewalk at the Market St. property. The motion failed by a 3-2 vote, with Council Members Larry Barnett, Bill Hauffle, and Jeanice Lester voting no.
Barnett said he voted against the replacement of the sidewalk due to agreement with Adams’ concerns.
“The kids are using the sidewalk on the east side of the street, and that’s the one they should use. I think he has a valid point. The kids aren’t walking on either side of that building,” Barnett said.
No further action was taken by the council.
