On the Side| Brad Hicks
If the Republican-dominated Iowa Legislature has designs on creating some sort of voucher program that allows tax dollars to follow a student to a private school or a home school, it ought to drop it right now. And it ought to do so on Republican principles.
The GOP always states its desire for smaller, more accountable government. It’s hard enough for the state to track where we spend all of the money on education. Can you imagine how difficult it will be to track dollars that follow students into private organizations?
Let’s get real. People pay taxes to run government operations. They don’t pay taxes to have their dollars fund private operations. And if that happens, there’s generally a public hearing that proposes and-or reviews where the money is going and how it’s going to be spent. The city of Red Oak’s relationship with the Red Oak Chamber and Industry Association might be an example of that. So, in the name of good government, are we going to have public hearings with private schools and individual home-schoolers to review how they are spending their money? Because in reality, that only seems the right thing to do to remain accountable for the people’s money. And in that vein, it seems crazy that Republicans would want to have programs in place that are less accountable for public dollars.
Other problems
Shifting dollars away from the public schools is going to cause other problems, too. Local schools aren’t going to get more authority to levy local property taxes, so they face budget problems, particularly if enrollment is shrinking. The argument that fewer students should result in less staff is one that’s often made. It’s a lame one, because the change compares apples and oranges. Let’s say that in a particular school district where there are 80 children per grade, the loss of eight children equates to the loss of revenue equal to employing one teacher. So, if the loss of those eight students occurs over eight grades, you have lost virtually none of the instruction load, but you’ve lost the revenue to employ a teacher. It’s a crunch that schools are facing all over Iowa.
Red Oak is in such a crunch. The district is looking for ways to cut instructional dollars. The letters on the Viewpoints pages this week point to concerns for the band program and proposed changes in it. The problem is that with the current school funding, the district doesn’t have a way to recoup dollars for lower enrollment. Something has to give. It will be up to the school board to make those choices. Now consider what it would be like if someone opened a private school in the Red Oak district and started laying claim to tax dollars that would follow the student there.
Parents should have choices in educating their children. But the people who pay property taxes within a certain school district should know that those property taxes are going to pay for their school, their city, their county, their 911 system, their community college system, etc. It’s even wrong to have property tax dollars collected in one school district follow a student to another school district under open enrollment – the state portion is fine, because that’s state revenue, but the local revenue ought to stay home.
The Republicans do something like this or try something like this just about every time they get into office. Instead of sticking to solid core values of making sure we squeeze the best we can out of the assets we have, they opt for some touchy-feely social issue that gets them into trouble. They ought to leave that stuff to the Democrats, the party of touchy-feely, and stick to making sure we have programs in place to make Iowa a better place. And, if that requires a tax increase, they ought not shy away from it.
Starved schools?
On the other hand, let’s not just buy the argument that Iowa has starved school districts nearly out of existence, which you often hear from the Democrats.
In 1996, the Red Oak Community School District had a budget of $8,923,828, with $4.7 million for instruction. The tax levy was $12.98 per $1,000 of assessed valuation.
In 2006, the district had a budget of $15,301,509, with $7.81 million for instruction. The tax levy was $14.60 per $1,000 of assessed valuation.
The proposed 2017 budget is for $24,336,335, with $10.17 million for instruction. The tax levy is proposed at $14.39 per $1,000 of assessed valuation.
The increase from 1996 to 2017 is $15,412,507, or 172.7 percent.
To put that into perspective, consider:
1. The federal government says that the purchasing power of $1 in 1996 equated to $1.57 in 2016 – an increase of 57 percent.
2. The Iowa Department of Revenue said total taxable personal income in 1996 in Montgomery County was $107,329,418. That was $174,038,834 in 2006, and was $204,957,701 in 2014, the most recent year the information is available. The change from 1996 to 2014 was $97,628,283, or 90.1 percent.
So, in review, the school district’s budget grew by 172.7 percent, the purchasing power of a dollar grew by 57 percent, and personal taxable income in the county grew by 90.1 percent.
The investment
These figures are not the final determination in terms of comparisons, because there are other factors that go into figuring out who is doing better than whom. But it does show that over time, school funding has kept pace with, if not exceeded, the growth in the value of the dollar and personal income of the county’s residents.
So, instead of the decades-long harangue, let’s all step back, realize the investment we make every year, and work to make the most of the dollars we invest in public schools. If people don’t want to have their children taught there, they have that right, but the taxpayers ought not be required to fund their right. The taxpayers ought to be reviewing what they get in return for their ever-growing investment.
Brad Hicks is publisher of The Express. Reach him at publisher@redoakexpress.com.
