Shopko should look beyond the numbers
I once had a math teacher who told me "numbers and statistics are like camouflage. They can hide a lot of things.”
ShopKo officials have decided to close Pamida instead of investing money into converting it into their store's format.
Their decision has been based on numbers and statistics that paint a picture depicting Red Oak as a one-store town, unwilling and unable to support a second general merchandise franchise.
And with Pamida's retail sales dominating that landscape, it seems to be a fair conclusion.
Its not.
This time, the numbers and statistics are hiding a sad reality ShopKo officials can't see: Red Oak's Pamida has dollar store merchandise inside a major retailer's building.
Let me be clear: I'm not criticizing dollar stores with that comment. My wife loves them and they have their place in the retail food chain. But that kind of inventory is not found inside a Target-sized store, which is what our Pamida is.
I knew from the moment I walked in the local Pamida three years ago that the combination of a giant store with its big overhead and lackluster inventory was going to be a fatal one.
In fact, I’m a little surprised it stayed open this long.
But it did, limping along with its lagging sales. And now, years later, those numbers are burying the potential that building has in this community.
If ShopKo officials want numbers and statistics to back up the argument Red Oak's economy is growing and capable of supporting the national retail chain, they don't need to look any further than the sales tax figures.
They have increased every year and there's no signs of them slowing down. I talk to local merchants periodically about how business is and the general mood is optimistic and positive. After dipping a few years ago with the national recession and several job closings, they are increasing.
Yet with most things, numbers can't entirely tell the story about Red Oak.
Sure sales are up and that should be enough. However, it doesn't have to be as Red Oak has a history of defying numbers and statistics.
Numbers and statistics would tell you Red Oak is too small for a YMCA with an indoor pool, tennis courts and racquetball courts, but there's one here anyway.
Numbers and statistics would tell you Red Oak is too small for a state-of-the-art performing arts center, but we have one of those too.
Numbers and statistics would tell you Red Oak was going to dry up and blow away after losing thousands of jobs, but instead, the town recruited three new industries in a year, including a DirecTV call center which replaced many of those lost jobs.
Numbers and statistics would tell you Red Oak's downtown was not a good place to invest money, public or private, but yet we have both with an energized, ongoing development project well underway.
Whether its job creation, private developments, recreati or simply the pride people take in their own residences, I've learned Red Oak simply isn't like other small towns. It doesn't fit the mold and it doesn't fit a pattern.
And it certainly can't be judged by a set of numbers.
I hope ShopKo officials can realize that too. If they don't, they may be ignoring a great opportunity hidden by a bunch of numbers.
Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com
