Sherman, school district agree to $100K settlement
RED OAK – The Red Oak School Board avoided a prolonged and potentially embarrassing legal fight by agreeing to a $100,000 settlement with high school principal Jedd Sherman.
The board voted to begin the termination process of Sherman in a May 5 meeting, and Sherman immediately filed an appeal that resulted in a scheduled July 2-3 hearing before an administrative law judge.
Both the school district and Sherman would be allowed to call witnesses to testify on their behalf, and attorneys would have been allowed to cross-examine those witnesses. While the hearing was scheduled to last two days, with the number of witnesses expected to testify, School Board President Lee Fellers said they had been advised it would likely last much longer than that.
Once the hearing was completed, the law judge would issue a ruling stating whether he believed Sherman should be terminated. However, the school board had the option of not accepting the ruling and proceeding with the termination, which Sherman could challenge in court. Had the judge agreed with the termination, Sherman still could have pursued legal recourse.
Because of this lack of closure, coupled with the expected length of the hearing and the looming start to the school year, Fellers said the board felt it was best to accept the settlement and move on with finding a replacement.
“The reason we accepted the resignation and settlement is it allowed us to move forward,” he said. “This could have been appealed all the way to the Iowa Supreme Court and dragged on literally for years. We have a mission to educate the students and being able to resolve this allows us to focus on that.”
Sherman seemed equally content with the opportunity to put the turmoil surrounding the end of his 6-year tenure in Red Oak behind him.
“The settlement itself is a blessing,” Sherman said. “By fighting my termination, I know I got a settlement I would have been offered, ordinarily.”
Sherman, whose annual salary was $87,500, said the settlement will give him time to find another job, ideally one in Red Oak.
“For sure, we are here next year and for sure, we are looking for a job so we can stay in Red Oak long term,” he said.
Sherman’s three children attend Red Oak schools, including his son Jared, who will be a senior this fall. His wife, Kara, is the executive director at the Wilson Performing Arts Center and both are active in the community through the Red Oak Rotary Club and their church.
Because of those ties to the community, Sherman hopes he and his family will be able to stay in Red Oak.
“We love Red Oak,” he said. “We don’t want to leave and won’t if I can find a job that allows us to stay here.”
As part of the settlement, the District agrees to pay Sherman $100,000 by Aug. 1 and will not challenge any unemployment claims he files, should he not be able to find a new job.
As for a replacement, the board conducted a special meeting Monday night to discuss options. Superintendent Terry Schmidt expected the board to look from within the district.
“At this point, 99 percent of qualified administrators in Iowa already have a contract in place for the upcoming school year” Schmidt said. “We are fortunate to have a strong administrative team already in place.”
The Red Oak Express will publish a story from that meeting on redoakexpress.com Tuesday.
The settlement has no bearing on Sherman’s complaint filed with the Iowa Public Information Board, accusing the school board of violating Iowa’s open meetings law. Sherman and Don Rogerson filed separate complaints stemming from meetings in April and May in which they accuse the board of discussing Sherman’s performance and evaluations in a closed session without his consent.
The IPIB recently accepted the complaints and begin a formal investigation into the matter.
