School board declines payment to Laughlin estate
RED OAK — Calling it a “heart-breaking” and “devastating” decision, Red Oak’s school board is following the advice of their auditor and attorney by not paying an early retirement settlement to the estate of Buck Laughlin.
Laughlin, a longtime Inman Primary School principal, negotiated the settlement with Superintendent Terry Schmidt, but failed to sign it before passing away May 21.
“The real piece for me was when our attorney told us we have no authority to make the payment,” Board President Lee Fellers said. “We want to do things correctly. It is important from an integrity standpoint to do things according to code.”
In his letter to the Board and Schmidt, Attorney Rick Engel recommended the board find another use for the estimated $34,000 payment.
“The District has a fiduciary responsibility to spend tax dollars only when authorized for reasons consistent with a public purpose,” Engel wrote. “The dollars that might have been spent for such a retirement payment if finalized will now instead be used as the Board directs to best serve the public purpose of educating its students.”
Fellers said had the agreement, which Laughlin had for more than two weeks, been signed, the funds would have come out of the management fund, pending board approval.
However, in absence of the signed legal document, the district’s auditor said the payment would have to come from the general fund, where the district’s everyday expenses are paid.
“The funds just aren’t available there,” Fellers said. “The general fund is where we pay the day-to-day expenses of operating the district.”
Schmidt said after negotiating the agreement he presented it Laughlin to sign, and asked him to do so on three separate occasions.
“I truly believe Buck intended to sign it,” Schmidt said. “I begged him to sign it.”
Laughlin’s sister, Barb Ray, said she doesn’t believe her brother fully realized the importance of his signature.
“He didn’t sign it because he trusted Mr. Schmidt would take care of it,” Ray said. “My brother put his faith in the system. They said they would look out for him and protect him, and they didn’t.”
Fellers said the district’s auditor stated if they paid the settlement from the management fund, it would show up “as a note” in the district’s next audit.
According to Iowa Code, tax funded entities such as school districts and city councils are required to hire a private firm to audit their finances, pursuant to guidelines established by the state’s auditor office.
Those audits are then reported to the state. Further recommendations can be made based on those audits, or if there is evidence of criminal activity such as embezzlement, the attorney general’s office can become involved.
However, according to State Auditor Chief of Staff Bernardo Granwehr, in the absence of criminal behavior, the auditor’s office can do nothing more than make recommendations.
“Government entities can ignore our recommendations if they wish,” Granwehr said. “Once in a while, an entity will make headlines for repeatedly ignoring our recommendations. But enforcement is really up to the citizenry.”
Granwehr added while an entity can do something that may violate Iowa code, and as such is illegal, it doesn’t mean the attorney general’s office is automatically called.
“A simple violation of the code doesn’t rise to the level of criminal behavior and an ensuing investigation,” he said.
Regardless of the Auditor’s ability to enforce their recommendations, school board member Elizabeth Dilley said she still can’t support violating the law.
“I don’t think we want to be in a situation where the school board starts to violate the Iowa code,” she said. “They (voters) have to have confidence we are following the law. I don’t want to be the one who starts a precedent of ignoring the law.”
Board Member Paul Griffen said it’s important for the Board to act as good stewards regarding public funds.
“It’s a question of following the law or not,” he said. “And do we have the authority to spend public funds without an agreement? I don’t think we do.”
Dilley shared Schmidt’s sentiments regarding the unfortunate circumstances surrounding the situation.
“It was very difficult for us (the board) to come to that decision,” she said. “We all wished he had signed that document. My heart really aches for Buck’s family.”
Griffen acknowledged Laughlin’s contributions to the District made the decision all the more difficult.
“It’s extremely unfortunate. Buck was a wonderful administrator,” he said. “We respected what he did and still respect what he did. He did a lot for the community and the school.”
Board Member Charla Schmid said considering all of Laughlin’s sacrifices and dedication to the school, she questions how he would respond to this issue.
“If I had done what he did for the past 25 years, how I would want my legacy to be left, would it be fighting over money? I think if Buck could come down for a minute, he would want his legacy to be something greater than that, and I agree. I have a lot of love for him,” Schmid said.
She also stressed how decisions like this affect the board members as people.
“Is the board human beings that has feelings? Yeah, we do,” she said. “We aren't mean terrible people trying to keep anything from people ... but we have to look at everything and how we are spending the money.”
While he deeply regrets not securing Laughlin’s signature, Schmidt said in his heart, he knows he tried.
“Buck was a friend of mine and a colleague of mine,” Schmidt said. “I would never do anything to hurt him.”
Schmidt said unless a board member tells him place the matter on a meeting agenda, discussion regarding the settlement is concluded.
“Someone could say ‘I would like to have on the board agenda the early retirement incentive package on Buck Laughlin, so we can have an up or down vote,’” Schmidt said. “And if it received three yes votes, we would pay it.”
While Schmidt doesn’t anticipate that happening, he agrees with Granwehr the consequences would be minimal.
“Would the State of Iowa do any more than send us a letter?” Schmidt asked. “I think we would just get slapped on the hand. But that’s just my opinion.”
Gray said she is undecided as to what to do next. “I have to decide what Buck would want me to do,” she said.
