RO school revises staff cuts
The Red Oak School Board took action on proposed staffing cuts at its regular meeting.
The cuts were proposed at the school board meeting Feb. 28, as a budget reduction measure. At that time, the cuts were expected to save the district roughly $590,000 in budget expenses next school year. Ultimately, a revised plan resulted in a projected $552,000 in reductions.
At a meeting Feb. 28, one of the proposed job cuts was a full-time instrumental music instructor, a move which was looked upon unfavorably in the community, according to superintendent Tom Messinger. As a result, at the Monday, March 13, meeting, Messinger presented a revised plan, intended to meet some of the needs outlined by community members and students.
“We received input from community members and from students. The revised cuts accomplish the same things in terms of budget, and meet the needs laid out by students and the community members,” Messinger said.
Messinger outlined the results to the school board, and indicated the cost savings numbers were rounded. The proposed cuts were:
First grade full-time instructor:
Cost savings: $47,000. Class size would reduce from four sections to three, at 18 kids per section. Due to a resignation, the cut would not result in a job loss to anyone in the district currently.
Third grade full-time instructor:
Cost savings: $51,000. Classes reduced from five sections to four, with roughly 20 students per section. Due to a resignation, this position also would not result in the loss of a job of anyone currently employed in the district.
Rather than eliminate the music instructor as initially proposed, Messinger said based on feedback, the cut had been revised.
“Washington Intermediate and the middle school vocal music teacher keeps the exact same schedule, as does the middle school instrumental teacher. The high school instrumental teacher continues with band responsibilities, including one period of band during the day and extracurricular activities as listed on the current and past schedules,” Messinger said.
Messinger added while there was no change on the schedule itself, the administration was looking to remove downtime during the day when there was no direct student contact time. As a result, the high school instrumental instructor would move to the middle school to teach middle school technology. This would result in no loss of any of the music instructors. To save money on the budget, there would be no hiring of a replacement for an instructor on a one-year leave of absence for the 2017-18 school year, saving the district $56,000.
Full time special education instructor:
One special education instructor would be cut at Washington Intermediate, a savings of $76,000. The cut was proposed due to a reduction of student numbers at Washington, and only 14 IEP students for 2017-18 at Washington. There was no job loss with this cut, as one employee resigned from the district.
Middle school/high school full-time social studies instructor:
Cost savings: $95,000. Due to compressed classes at the middle school, it eliminated the need for an instructor at the building. At the high school, one period of world studies would have an increased class size to 30 students, or one special education teacher at the high school would teach one period of world studies. The position is vacant due to an early retirement approved at the Feb. 28 board meeting.
Full time building administrator:
Cost savings: $131,000. Remaining administrators would cover all evaluations. Administrative duties would be redefined and distributed utilizing strengths of personnel.
Three full-time paraprofessional positions:
Cost savings: $96,000. The position cuts were the result of early retirements. Duties would be reassigned. They would only be replaced if IEP called for services unable to be provided by the current staff.
Total budget reductions: $552,000.
Following the presentation from Messinger, the board opened up the meeting to public comment on the proposed cuts. The first to comment was Red Oak High School vocal music instructor Tim Marsden, who stressed that any type of cut to the music department would cut out opportunities for the students, especially at the high school.
“At the high school, we have district music contest, which can’t be practiced for during regular class time. There are solos, duets, and trios involved. Dan Black and I handle lessons every chance in the day we can get. The same type of scenario goes with other competition events. It takes a lot of time for individual practices for band and choir students. We go beyond one period in the contact we have to help our students, I just want the board to consider that,” Marsden said.
Kara Sherman addressed the board next, on behalf of the Wilson Performing Arts Center and the music boosters. Sherman said studies had shown student learning through musical education equipped students with the foundational ability to learn and achieve in other core academic courses.
“Those that are exposed to music are using every part of their brain. That being said, with 1,089 students in the district, 905 students are involved in music. It impacts 84 percent of our school. You can’t forget that. I’m concerned about lessons throughout the day that can’t be done during regular class time,” Kara said.
Sherman presented the board with a petition signed by 100 residents supporting music in education, and assurances they were getting the best education possible.
Abigail Sherman addressed the board as well, speaking on behalf of the students who may not be comfortable speaking with the board. Abigail said she felt music was the biggest part of culture at the school.
“I believe music holds a central part of our school culture, and gives us an amazing reputation in the arts. I’ve been to many competition where students can’t believe we have such a strong music program, and express a desire to come to our school. I’m concerned about the lesson plan however. There are many times students are practicing music that don’t show up on the schedule. It’s very important we keep on having discussions about this. Many things are impacted by the arts, and we need them,” Abigail commented.
Another community member to address the board was Anne Bennett. Bennett read from a letter written by her daughter Maggie, who graduated from Red Oak in 2014.
“As a recent graduate, I know what the music departments are like. The music departments were always my home. I felt like I belonged in a musical setting. I felt like I could express myself in a way that I hadn’t yet learned to do in visual arts. Music is an expression of the soul, not only from me but from many of my peers in the music department. If even one of the instructors were cut due to funding issues, it would be a great loss to the music community, and to the students, whom you should be thinking of,” quoted Bennett.
Larry Brandstetter said curriculum would not be changed by many of the cuts that had been proposed. However, he felt that the proposed changes to the music schedule would result in a curriculum change.
“You approved the curriculums used by our arts teachers. If you take the high school band teacher out of the classroom all day long, and give them only one period of class per day, and extracurriculars, what does that do to the elements of the curriculum that the instructor has been hired to teach? How will it affect the assessments of the students. I don’t think that has been taken into consideration. I think it’s assumed that the curriculum won’t change. I would wager if you ask the instructors what kind of an impact this will have on the curriculum, they will tell you they can’t teach the type of curriculum he’s been hired to teach, because he won’t have the time with the students to do so,” Brandstetter said.
The last to speak was Jedd Sherman, who proposed an option of eliminating family insurance plans as an effort to save money without hurting the classroom, stating it was a national trend.
“The premium for family plans for administrators is worth $100,000 a year roughly for the district. The revenue per student is $6,591. We use a lot of students to pay for the plans, which is not going to the classrooms. Family plans for administrators is currently standard practice, but who says we have to keep doing things in a standard fashion. How does a family medical plan for administration improve the education of our children? I don’t know that it does. For the board members: Why would you not want to save money so that we can provide a better education for our kids? The money saved is worth two teaching positions at the elementary building. I think it’s a great opportunity,” said Jedd Sherman.
Board member Kathy Walker expressed her appreciation for the public comments, and for the music instructors for their work for the district, and said the budget cuts the district faced were unfortunate.
“I think this is the best option for the district right now, and I believe this is an ongoing discussion in the future,” Walker said.
Board member Bryce Johnson said he also appreciated the comments from the public, and said that they have made every board member thing about the future of the school.
“This is one of the hardest decisions I’ve had to make on the school board. Red Oak is a great community, and the school is a great part of the community,” Johnson said.
The board unanimously approved the revised budget reductions proposed as presented.
