Response to Moffett
I was concerned about the recent letter to the editor, dated Oct. 30. Marta Moffett made it sound like using telemedicine for medical abortions was not dangerous. As a board certified family physician who has been providing obstetric care for more than 20 years, I disagree. Telemedicine abortions are neither safe nor compassionate. I am ethically opposed to abortion, but even if I were not I would be against telemedicine abortions for the sake of my patients.
The drugs used for medical abortions causes significant cramping and bleeding. In fact, the drug company has a black box warning on the medication stating about eight percent of patients will drop their Hemoglobin by 2gm/dl, which is the equivalent of 750ml or more than three cups of blood. Unfortunately if the woman has heavy bleeding and needs to be seen, the Planned Parenthood clinic is only open five-seven hours, three days per week, so they are not there for the patient to do a surgical procedure to stop the bleeding if required.
The drug company also states the healthcare provider should follow up with the patient at day three and day 14, after taking the initial medication. By day three, the patient may need medications for cramping and gastrointestinal symptoms like nausea, vomiting and diarrhea, but Planned Parenthood does not have them follow up at this time. Planned Parenthood only has them follow up on Day 14 to see if the pregnancy has completely terminated. If the drugs did not work completely, the patient has to have a surgical abortion, which requires them to pay more money. In fact, prior to the patient receiving the initial medication, she is required to sign a statement that states she will get a surgical abortion if the medical abortion is not successful. I realize this is difficult to believe, but go to the Planned Parenthood website under abortion services and you will see this is true.
I have prescribed similar drugs for women who have miscarried, but have not yet passed their baby. I counsel them extensively on the risks of a medical miscarriage, see them back every 24 hours, and either I or a partner is available via telephone to come in to evaluate them, in case they need a surgical procedure due to bleeding or other problems.
However, my job as a physician is not just to provide patients with excellent medical care, but also to treat them compassionately and respectfully. An unplanned pregnancy is a very difficult situation for many women. I have discussed this circumstance with many patients; I have cried with them, held their hand and talked with them through this tough time, during multiple visits and phone calls. I strongly encourage them to consider options other than abortion for two reasons. They have a human being growing inside of them that has as many rights as the patient I am treating, and this baby is my patient too. In addition, many women experience significant turmoil for many years after having an abortion, and I do not want my patient to have regrets. Some of my patients decide to parent, others allow their child to be adopted and others decide to have an abortion, but no matter the choice, I continue to love and care for them, something patients cannot have through telemedicine with a provider they never meet in person. Providing compassionate care includes human touch and face-to-face care.
I have used telemedicine to care for some of my patients, when necessary, and when safety is not a factor. Telemedicine is an excellent way to provide care in many situations; however, pregnancy termination is not one of them. When prescribing high risk medications, the prescribing provider or one of their partners needs to be available to handle the complications and provide compassionate, safe care. Women can and have died from medical abortions, their physician needs to be locally available.
As stated earlier, I am ethically opposed to abortions. It saddens me in the United States I can be charged with a felony, fined up to $250,000 and spend up to two years in jail for killing bald eagles or damaging their eggs (a species which is no longer on the endangered list but is protected by the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act). However, I only need to pay a few hundred dollars to kill a baby growing in my womb, and there is no fine or jail time. Has America lost its perspective? Or simply its humanity?
Five states including Nebraska have deemed telemedicine abortions illegal. Unfortunately, women from both Nebraska and Missouri are crossing statelines to come to Red Oak for their telemedicine abortions. Do we really want Red Oak to be known as the abortion destination site? Does this really make Red Oak “a shade better”?
Patricia Goodemote, MD, is from Villisca.
