Public weighs in on comms

Discussion on a proposed multi-million dollar upgrade to the county’s communications system brought a capacity crowd to the public forum at the Montgomery County courthouse courtroom Jan. 17.

The forum was an informational meeting to discuss a proposal from Motorola, which received the state bid for the statewide system, at a cost of roughly $5.28 million with discounts. Montgomery County Emergency Management coordinator Brian Hamman updated the crowd on the state of the current communications system, which is roughly 20 to 40 years old. Communications in the county are provided through a number of locations, some more secure than others, including power poles, an abandoned windmill, a water tower, and a radio tower.

According to Hamman, the high cost of the project is due in part because the county is building new communications from the ground up, and requires three new towers to be built to handle the communications. Plans also include the county joining the Iowa Statewide Interoperable Communications System, a move undertaken by Page and Mills County. The counties also approved multimillion dollar upgrades to their own communications systems. The matter is under consideration in Fremont County as well.

Repayment

Funding for the project would be paid through a general obligation bond. Mike Summers with D.A. Davidson Company shared the tax impact to county residents during the informational meeting.

• A 15-year general obligation bond generated an annual average payment of $481,670, and the levy impact was $0.7934 per $1,000 valuation.

• A 20-year GO bond which generated an annual average payment of $411,941, with a levy impact of $0.6785 per $1,000 valuation.

The need

Members of law enforcement and fire and rescue personnel who work with the county’s current system also addressed the crowd. Dispatch supervisor Jackie Laire discussed the stress she and other dispatchers face when they are unable to communicate with law enforcement personnel on calls due to failures in communications, in part due to narrow banding of the VHF channels.

“With the narrow banding we’ve already had, and the narrow banding we’ve been told is coming, it makes this system upgrade a need, not a want. We in the dispatch center feel this is a must,” Laire said.

Red Oak Fire Chief John Bruce said the system has continued to fail his staff, as well as other emergency responders throughout the county. Bruce said what was expected of emergency services had escalated, as well as threats to law enforcement and the fire service and EMS providers. Bruce said the number one tool available for their safety was communications, and the county’s system was failing.

“We have become our own worst enemy because we did not advertise this to you. That was dumb because we didn’t have much for options in those times, and it was a security issue. The last thing we wanted to do was advertise this weak link we see in the system, because now it’s out there, and shows it could be very easy to knock out our communications. However, it’s our responsibility as chiefs to get everyone home. Once again, the tool to make that happen is communications. We are playing Russian roulette with destiny, and that could mean we bury somebody,” Bruce said.

Red Oak Police Chief Justin Rhamy said since the new system was proposed, there had been three radio outages, which no one knew until the paging failed. He also cited an incident on Thanksgiving, 2015 involving an officer on a traffic stop.

“He got involved in a fight with the suspect. He was seven blocks south of us and started getting choked, and the radio wouldn’t work. Thankfully our dispatchers suspected something was odd and sent out reinforcements. Finally, he was able to get his radio operational and he hollered ‘Help! He needs help.’ That’s what he was hollering,” Rhamy said. “In 2014, we had a shooting on 4th Ave. We had 78 first responders from over 40 agencies in our community, including law enforcement from Missouri and Omaha. We couldn’t talk to them on our radios, because we had no interoperable communications. Communications are imperative for what we do on a daily basis. All of our men and women in uniform rush into danger on any given day. We need every tool on our tool belt when we run towards that danger, and we are lacking one of the most critical and imperative tools on our tool belt.”

Public response

Red Oak resident and business owner Michael Luna spoke during public comments and said the information shared was disturbing.

“Two different times my wife had to call 911 to have me taken from my house. Now I know it’s possible that no one could have heard that call. I’m very disturbed. I don’t like to pay taxes. In fact, I hate it. But I have never seen anything more worthy than this project,” Luna said.

The question was raised if the county had given thought to what it may cost down the road to maintain the system, and what budgeting could be done to plan for those costs. Hamman said steps were being taken.

“Motorola has offered post-warranty services as well as a system upgrade plan for joining the statewide system. That cost to begin with is $107,000. After a ten year agreement, it increases to roughly $131,000. That is a lot of money, but for the technology, the advancements we’re making, the investment, and the infrustructure we will have at that point compared to what we have now is next to none,” Hamman said.

Supervisor Donna Robinson said the supervisors work on budgets every year. If the county moves forward with the proposal, the supervisors will have to look at it every year and figure out how the numbers work into their budget every year.

Chief Rhamy’s wife Sydney asked the audience to think about what would happen if they needed to call emergency responders for a fire, or other emergency situation, and how quickly they would want response.

“If they have to take the time to run back to their radio to call for help, or stop CPR to call for help, that’s a dangerous situation. With this new radio system, we have to put the impact on our first responders, but we have to put it on the community as well. The average median household in the county is $85,000. That’s $38. What’s more important? Your loved ones, or that $38?” Sydney asked.

Ron Nelson asked if Chat Mobility had any part in the project. Hamman said they were not a part of the plan. The new tower will be located near the chat mobility tower, but because of the cost of rent, it was more feasible to build a brand new tower than pay the rent on the existing Chat Mobility tower.

One audience member asked if the public should vote on the the project, rather than leave the decision to the supervisors. Clint Rubey was against the idea, said he was skeptical of the needs, and the cost of the project, but the presentation had impressed him and changed his mind. He urged the supervisors to make the right choice.

“The public is not always right. If we vote on this, and it gets voted down, that’s criminal. There’s a need here that goes beyond the democratic system. I know the supervisors are distressed by the amount of money you are looking at. This is a representative democracy, and not everything that has to be done has to be voted on. That’s why we voted for you guys,” Rubey said. “Sometimes you have to make a tough decision, even when it seems a majority of the public is against it. I don’t think there’s a person left in this room tonight that’s against it. We’re hoping to find a cheaper way to pay for it, and we’re depending on you to research that and figure out of there is a cheaper way to pay for it. It’s criminal to send our emergency responders out into dangerous situations with radios that may not work.”

Keith Larson also spoke during the meeting, and said he was a taxpayer, and said he was supportive of the project.

“I don’t care what the cost is. How can we in good judgment say no to this. We’ve been lucky so far. If something serious goes down at our school, and we don’t get a decent response because of a failure of communication, I wouldn’t want that burden on my shoulders. How many cell phones have we all had? We can’t wait on the greatest technology, because in six months, it will be outdated. We cannot wait to keep these guys protected as much as we can,” Larson said.

Some audience members in attendance encouraged the supervisors to consider a bond that would allow for a pay off in 10 years or less, and the supervisors agreed to research those numbers.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here