Poor communication frustrates downtown business owners

RED OAK — Streets are closing; dump trucks are rolling through town, and dust is filling the air. Yes, the downtown street and sidewalk project has kicked into hyper gear to meet its November deadline.

However, the promised communication between the city and contractor and business owners has not been up to par, leading to frustration on all sides.

At a pre-construction meeting several months ago, it was discussed that the Chamber and Industry Association would send out weekly updates notifying downtown businesses where the construction crew would be working. However, according to Pudgy Pumpkin Patch owner Elaine Hollen, this hasn’t been happening.

During a presentation at last week’s City Council meeting, Hollen said not knowing where the crew from Carley Construction, LLC will be has impacted her business.

“September sales were down from a year ago, and I’m not saying it’s all on this,” Hollen said. “It needs to be done; someone was going to trip on those bricks. I’ve been positive, but I just want to know if there’s any way we can have some kind of communication.”

Hollen added knowing where the crews would be working and what streets were going to be closed in advance could allow her to plan better. For example, she may not need a full staff one day because the street is closed, or she said she could put up signs encouraging people to use the back door instead and offer back door specials to entice customers.

In response to Hollen’s concern at the Council meeting, City Engineer Pete Crawford said he has weekly meetings with Carley Construction and was under the impression they had been keeping in touch with the businesses.

During an interview with The Red Oak Express, Crawford said the contractor was contacting the businesses affected by the construction on a day-to-day basis. The Association, who was supposed to be supplied information for a weekly update though, was not given the contractor’s schedule by the city to inform all the businesses each week. So, when Henningsen Construction of Atlantic came to lay the asphalt, the lines of communication became even more skewed.  

With Henningsen working on the streets and Carley on the sidewalks, downtown has become even more chaotic with twice as many crews and trucks — what Red Oak Mayor Bill Billings referred to as “an ant hill that’s been stepped on.”

Crawford added he has been in contact with both contractors since last Monday’s Council meeting, and they are working to improve communication by beginning the promised weekly updates from the Association.

Hollen, who was the sole downtown representative at the Council meeting, is not alone in her frustration; other business owners and managers echoed the annoyance a lack of communication has produced.  

Taylor Willers from Brown’s Shoe said Tuesday she was informed that morning there would be construction in front of her store that afternoon, leaving little time to prepare.

“We have a lot of older ladies who come to the store, some of them with walkers and wheelchairs, and it’s a hassle for them,” Willers said. “If they have to walk far, they don’t come.”

Similar to Hollen, Willers said she might have to open her back door to customers, but doesn’t want to if it isn’t necessary because it is not as accessible to the public.

Following the trend, Jan Norris of Parker Norris Financial said she was also under the impression they would know in advance when streets and sidewalks were to be closed, and she hoped to schedule appointments accordingly.

However, she was thankful the sidewalk work in front of her building was done throughout two days, allowing one door to always remain open.  

“It’s a temporary pain for a permanent gain,” Norris said. “It’s like growing pains really and we will all be happy when it’s done.”

James Norris, Jan’s husband, added their business is unique because they don’t rely on customers just passing by. Therefore, he doesn’t suspect the construction will harm their business, but he said it could likely impact the retail outlets on the square.

Family Vision Office Manager Dori Hampel said she too is frustrated by the lack of communication but also the changing of plans.

“Before it started, we were under the impression they would be working on one side of the square at a time,” Hampel said. “But, they have the whole thing torn up and when people see the road blocks, they don’t want to come. It discourages them.”

Family Vision has a doctor on site two days a week, and Hampel said she has been trying to schedule appointments according to construction, which has required the doctors to switch days. However, not knowing where crews will be working has made it difficult.

Hampel also expected to know week-by-week what part of the square was to be worked on when. However, construction crews came in Wednesday a few hours after they began working on the street in front of Family Vision to tell her the street would be torn up.  

“I wish they would have kept with the plan because it would help direct people where to park,” Hampel said. “Our older patients can’t just walk two blocks so we’ve kept a close eye on the schedule to move older patients to different days, and some are just waiting until it’s all over.”

Crawford explained delays and setbacks have required plans to change to meet the deadline.  

“He started a whole month later than I thought the latest should have been,” Crawford said at the Council meeting about Carley Construction. “That’s really put a lot of challenge in the whole job. The challenge for everybody now is to get it done in an accelerated way.”

The project also faced setbacks early on when there were conflicts with the location of utility lines on the corners of the square where concrete planters are being constructed.

Originally, three blocks were to be torn up at once, only one of which was to be on the square, with cars either being able to traverse around the square or exit at the intersections. Because of delays, though, Crawford said they’ve had to increase that number to about six blocks at a time still keeping in mind an entire street and intersection cannot be closed at once.

“When you do the streets it’s a different deal,” Crawford said. “There is no way to keep it to a three block minimum and even get close to getting it done.”

The sidewalk work is scheduled to be completed by Nov. 1, with a large portion complete by Thursday to not interfere with Trick or Treat Around the Square. There are then eight to 10 days worth of asphalt work to be done, which is contingent upon the weather. Crawford said it’s too early to say if the Nov. 15 deadline will be kept.

The contractor from Carley Construction did not respond to multiple requests for an interview regarding this story.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here