Dust control a heated topic at supervisors

Nick Johansen

The Red Oak Express

The Montgomery County Board of Supervisors met in regular session on April 9.

The supervisors met with Paul Heffron of Heffron Services, Inc. regarding the county’s dust control program. In April, 2018 when accepting quotes from dust control companies, the supervisors received two quotes, one from Jerico Services, Inc., and the other from Heffron. While the quote from Jerico was higher, the supervisors were advised that they did not have to accept the lowest quote and had control over the vendor they chose.

After citing multiple complaints over the dust control services provided by Heffron when their quote was chosen for dust control services prior, the supervisors chose to accept the higher quote provided by Jerico.

Heffron said he had been in contact with county engineer Brad Skinner about when the selection process was to begin, and had been advised the decision was made at the board level as to whether multiple vendors would be asked for quotes. Heffron said services had been provided by the company until recently.

“We’ve provided quotes in the past, and up until a couple years ago, the quote was accepted, even though the homeowners pay for the service. We work in a trade area of about two-thirds of the state of Iowa, and in the other counties we work in, the homeowners pick and choose the services they want, like a garbage collector, and can choose the price and service levels. I’m addressing you to see if the policy would remain the same this year, or if the homeowners can sell directly to the customers,” Heffron said.

Heffron added that he was aware the quote provided last year was the lower quote, but the award went to their competitor, and also said he had heard reports of service-level issues in the company in the county, though he was not specifically aware of them.

Supervisor Mark Peterson said he had called Heffron’s office several years ago around the time the dust control selection process was taking place that year, and said residents were confused as to whom they needed to contact.

“I told the person I was not telling them how to run their business, but in the past it’s been advertised on our local radio and in the local paper. I was told you advertise on WHO Radio, which I’m sure works well in Dallas and Polk County, but there aren’t that many who listen to WHO Radio down here. Also, I was told the application could be accessed on the internet. That wasn’t acceptable to me,” Peterson said.

Heffron said radio advertising did not work well for them, and they had discontinued radio advertising. Heffron said the requirements were to mail to everyone who had the service the prior two years, which they did, and they were asked to advertise in the local newspapers.

Supervisor Bryant Amos said he used dust control services, and did so the last year Heffron put it down, and noticed issues.

“They came through and put it down, and within hours, I couldn’t tell they had put it down. I don’t know if the operator wasn’t using the right amount, or what was going on, but it was not effective. Also that year, we had some scheduling issues with our own roads department. We go out and dress the areas up before it’s applied, and it seemed that year the roads were dressed up and then it was delayed before it was put down,” Amos said.

Skinner said he remembered one complaint in particular from a garbage hauler with a facility on a gravel road, and he said they received several complaints from them that they were unable to get results. Skinner said the more organizations involved in the process, the more coordination was needed.

“Even dealing with two can become cumbersome. It’s hard to get coordinated with more than one entity. Logistically, it’s much more practical for us to have just one, which is behind our philosophy of just one. Also, the expense for the county is probably double what it is for the individuals who apply for the dust control,” commented Skinner.

Heffron said they had not been contacted about providing a quote this year, and said they wished to be able to contract directly with homeowners for services as they do in other counties.

Skinner said the operational issues they had with multiple contractors were difficulty in keeping track of inventory and keeping grader operators informed about multiple sets of dust control locations.

“We’ve had people do it privately, and the grader operator hasn’t been made aware of it. The operator blades through it, then we have complaints that we bladed out their dust control. We have typically tried to simplify the process to make it more workable.

Supervisors Chairman Mike Olson and the other supervisors advised they received no complaints from residents during the dust control operations performed by Jerico. Olson said that wasn’t the case in the past.

“The first two years, and especially last year at this time, people weren’t happy with Heffron. I’m sorry, they just weren’t. About half a dozen of them said if we went with Heffron again, we wouldn’t use it. So that formulates what goes on here, what we hear from the public, because they’re paying for it,” Olson said.

Heffron said if the public didn’t want to use their company, that was the market at work. Olson said the county still had to coordinate dust control with the secondary roads department to make it work.

“We’ve already got expenses involved in this, and if we have to make special trips, because Company A did this, and Company B did this. If we open this up, we could have multiple companies coming in here. That to me looks like a logistical nightmare for our secondary roads department,” Olson said.

Heffron said there were no other counties in the state where they did business that there was only one provider, and said they provided services to roughly 47 counties.

“In Madison County, where I live, the county sets a date where the roads will be prepped. After that date, all the roads are prepped, and it’s up to the contractors to get out and do the work. If one of the contractors doesn’t perform, the other entities will take that business,” commented Heffron.

Heffron added that in the counties that have multiple contractors, once the roads are prepped the county’s involvement was done. Olson disagreed.

“Even though it is their responsibility, and they pay for it, it comes right back to this table. They were not happy. It may have only been six or eight calls total, but they were not happy. Last year, we had no complaints about the dust control whatsoever.

Amos said in 14 years, he knows of no complaints from citizens about their method or policy, save for one who didn’t agree with the dust control material being used.

“We’ve had no complaints about how we do it, or our decision in using one company,” Amos said.

Attorney Bruce Swanson, who was in attendance, said since the service wasn’t being paid for by the county, it did not have to be put out for a quote.

The supervisors took no action following the discussion.  

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here