Red Oak board talks staffing cuts

Nick Johansen

The Red Oak Express

More than 50 citizens attended the Monday, Jan. 14, Red Oak Board of Education meeting about staffing and budget reductions.

Red Oak Superintendent Tom Messinger explained cuts were necessary in order to prevent the district from spending beyond its authorized spending limit, which is authorized by the Iowa Department of Education.

Based on data from Forecast5, which was used to determine the future financials for the district, the reduction of five teachers, three para-educators, and one secretary in the 2019-20 school year was recommended by Messinger. Additionally, two teaching positions would be eliminated in the 2020-21 school year.

With a continued loss of enrollment, despite the staffing cuts, Messinger said the district is still projected to spent 99.9 percent of its authorized budget in 2024.

Among the curriculum impacted by the staffing reductions were cuts to art classes and vocal music. Community members who addressed the board during the public comment period were overwhelmingly against making cuts to the arts. Mary Fields, whose son Sam is an eighth grader at Red Oak Middle School, outlined some of the many accomplishments Sam had thanks to his experiences in band.

“Mrs. Wemhoff laid the foundation in elementary school and created a curiosity and desire to choose to be in middle school band and choir. We have a marvelous music team in Red Oak, an award-winning team. Each member of the department makes up a five-run ladder. Which of those rungs are you willing to chop away? How big of a gap are you willing to see these students have to jump to get the same results this music program has already seen to this point? You shouldn’t try to fix something that isn’t broken,” Fields said.

Ed Stickland also addressed the board and said the music program of the Red Oak District is one of the best he’s seen, though he understood the board’s position.

Kara Sherman outlined the sheer number of students participating in the arts.

“We have 1,086 students in the district. 950 of those students are in music, and 933 in art. We’re asking to cut our teachers when we only have five people handling those 950 kids in music, and three handling 933 students in art? It makes no sense to me. The kids are here. This is what they believe in, and this is what we thrive in. Take that away, and it’s only going to hurt our school district,” Sherman said.

Another community member advocating for saving school arts programs was Larry Brandstetter.

“I know you have to make cuts due to the loss of students. Over the past three or four years, we have lost about 130 students, which is a tremendous amount. When you take that times $6,800 per student, it amounts to a great deal of our budget. I would hope that the board sits down and gets the analysis of where these people go, if you haven’t done that already,” Brandstetter said.

He added how difficult it would be for the remaining teachers if numerous staffing cuts were made.

“If you were to say to the high school coach that you were going to eliminate all of the assistants, and tell them they are going to get all the teams and players from grades seven through twelve, you would lose them. That’s what’s being said to our instrumental music teachers. If you cut one of those two teachers, you’re telling them they will have all the students in those grades, they’ll have to give all the lessons, prepare all the students for concerts, get ready for two bands for the concerts, and prepare for all the contests in junior high and high school. One person is going to be in charge of all that programming. You wouldn’t dare do that to anyone else. Quality is going to be sacrificed. It’s on your shoulders if the quality goes down. I hope it’s a decision you don’t want to make,” commented Brandstetter.

The last person to speak was elementary art instructor Teresa Euken, who said the staffing cuts were a reason behind her decison to retire, which she did Jan. 14.

“I will not be a part of that with our students. I’m very sorry to say that because most people go in and they are excited and happy to retire, but it was not happy for me. It was nothing to celebrate. This was not the way I thought I would go out but I’m not going to have K-sixth in art. I hate to do that to my students because I truly love these kids. I love them to pieces, but I’m not going to do that,” Euken said.

Board member Mark Johnson addressed the crowd following the public comment period, advising of the financial situation the district was in. The district received $6,731 per student in Supplemental State Aid from the State of Iowa last year. The money makes up a part of the district’s general fund.

“Over 80 percent of general fund dollars go to salaries and benefits, while the other 20 percent goes to utilities, fuel, and things of that nature. Over the last three years, Red Oak has seen a drop of over 100 students. The Supplemental State Aid has decreased by $673,000. This is money we lose every year. It’s not hard to see that the loss of that much revenue to the general fund will have a large impact on salaries and benefits,” Johnson said.

Johnson added it was a violation of state law to exceed its spending authority, and if it happened, the board would have to appear before the State Budget Review Committee with a plan to fix the situation.

“If it isn’t fixed, the state will come in and make the cuts to correct the situation,” commented Johnson.

Also, Johnson said next year the district will close one building, and now was the time to most effectively use their resources to make the proper alignments.

The board will vote on staffing cuts at its Jan. 28 meeting.  

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here