Survey Says...
The Red Oak Community School District School Improvement Advisory Committee held the second of three meetings for improving student achievement.
At a previous meeting, superintendent Tom Messinger shared the details of the district report card from the Iowa Department of Education. The middle school and high school dropped from “acceptable” to “priority” ratings based on several factors, including Iowa Assessment scores and teacher retention numbers.
Administrators then reached out to high school and middle school students and teachers with a survey, which asked questions to determine discrepancies between students and staff. The middle school survey results were reviewed by the advisory committee last week; the high school results were not yet available.
Based on the middle school survey, students felt note taking, creating something, and completing worksheets were the most successful aids in student learning. According to the student survey, they also felt that learning in small groups was the most effective method, rather than working as a whole class, working alone, or working one-on-one with a teacher.
LeAnn Fluckey, who gave a breakdown of the results of the student and teacher surveys, said students also found a benefit to problem solving and discussion when it came to student learning. However, there were certain learning activities that the students felt were not effective.
“Presenting and writing activities were considered the least effective. However, while those were not as preferred, a third of the students still found those activities effective. What we’re finding out is that the differentiation is huge for us. We’re going to have to keep working in that direction,” Fluckey said.
When discussing technology, 49.1 percent of the students felt technology was somewhat engaging and increased their interest in learning, with 44.2 percent definitely agreeing technology increased their engagement and interest in learning.
The student responses were positive in regards to student/teacher relationships, content/instruction, and classroom management.
As for school culture, 97 percent of students felt valued, and the numbers were the same for questions regarding the staff treating everyone fairly and caring about students. However, 17 percent of students felt that the teachers did not create positive relationships with their families, and 20 percent said they would not feel comfortable talking to their teacher if someone treats them unfairly.
Students also commented about the general condition of the building and the bathrooms, and asked for more class choices.
As for the teacher survey, the teachers said they felt that discussion, problem solving, and creating something were the most effective methods for student learning. While they were in agreement with the students on creating something as a method for learning, none of the teachers surveyed thought that note taking and completing worksheets was very effective, which differed from the student results.
While some of the teachers felt working in small groups was an effective method of learning, the teachers surveyed felt working one-on-one with them was the most effective, with every teacher saying it was effective to very effective. 75 percent of the teachers felt technology was an effective learning tool and increased student engagement some of the time, and 25 percent were in complete agreement.
Fluckey noted that there would be disparities in the survey percentages, as only 20 teachers took the survey, as opposed to 224 students at the middle school.
The committee broke into small groups to discuss the results of the survey, and additional discussion took place regarding the results of the report card.
Questions were raised during the meeting about the attendance of the meetings and lack of parental participation. Suggestions were offered to have the meetings held in other schools, such as Inman Primary, where children could be supervised while their parents met.
“I’m seeing professional people, and students taking AP courses and extra curriculars. We need to get the at-risk students and parents in here and have them weigh in on what they think is the cause of why they’re not doing well, and have their parents in here so we can ask them, rather than rely solely on their peers answering,” said Red Oak resident Peggy Boeye.
Superintendent Tom Messinger said that the biggest reasons parents don’t go to school is because they don’t feel comfortable approaching teachers, according to studies.
“It becomes more of an issue of getting them comfortable with that, and how we get them doing that. If a student knows their parent is going to be in communication with a teacher, that makes a difference as well,” Messinger said.
The committee will have one more meeting in April, and the final results of the committee will be presented at one of the upcoming school board meetings.
