Letter to | the Editor
To the Editor:
Monday, Feb. 27, the superintendent of the Red Oak School District made a recommendation to the school board that a music teacher be pink-slipped in order to save money. Let’s take a look at the consequences to student learning, student involvement, the impact of our community pride, and the overall quality of our superior music program this action would bring about.
The superintendent’s recommendation really looks like this: The high school band director would be reassigned to grades 4-8 general music. The middle school band director would be reassigned to 6-12 Band. The current 4-8 music teacher would be eliminated. The high school choir director would stay as is.
On the surface, this all looks like a shuffling of the deck with all programs still staffed, but with one less teacher. Upon taking a deeper look, the changes would produce the following: The new high school/middle school band director would be in charge of both middle and high school concert bands, both middle and high school jazz bands, both middle and high school marching bands, both middle and high school individual and group lessons, both middle and high school music contest student preparation, and, starting sixth grade band with group and private lessons.
The word that comes to mind is “overwhelming.” All this is with a current instrumental program student enrollment of more than 140 students.
The second potential impact on our quality music program would be the elimination of the 4-8 general music teacher and replaced with the current high school band director. The curriculum taught at the intermediate level has to have a teacher who knows and loves teaching at that age group. Our high school band teacher has no experience teaching upper elementary students. On paper he may be qualified, but we may lose this quality and innovative teacher to a school where he can continue to teach high school band. This is akin to asking the high school football coach to move to elementary PE, or asking the high school calculus teacher to move to elementary math. This is not the best use of teaching talent.
Last, and maybe the most threatening to our outstanding music program is that the teacher being cut is the spouse of the high school choral teacher and director of our award-winning chorus and superb spring musical productions.
Here is the threat. A family income would be cut in half. The potential is strong that this outstanding family may have to move to a school district where they can both teach and raise their family in order to provide adequate income. We live in a world where both husband and wife have to work to provide for the family. We could lose the Marsden family, and possibly the Hewett family, from our community because of the short-sightedness of our superintendent and school board.
These are the implications of the superintendent’s recommendation as they relate to the outstanding music department in the Red Oak Community Schools. The law of “unintended consequences” will be resting with our superintendent and school board. Red Oak has been known for generations for its quality music programs. We are not ready to put that hard-earned reputation into jeopardy for a small savings.
Please call each member of the Red Oak School Board and encourage them to vote “no” on this proposal when they meet on Monday, March 13. The dominoes are ready to be pushed over and a quality fine arts program for which Red Oak is well known and our citizens are so proud, is about to be diminished significantly.
Larry Brandstetter, Red Oak retired middle school
fine arts teacher
Larry Mannasmith, Red Oak retired high school
choral teacher
Marlys Conrad, Red Oak retired middle dchool
music teacher
Paul and Deb Jepson, former Red Oak band directors
