The Time Capsule | Roy Marshall
An article written by Dr. Michael Farrell of Cornell University in Ithaca, N.Y., has me tapping trees and remembering Henry Huffy.
Huffy, an old man with a white beard when I knew him, used tree sap to make syrup. I was then about 12, helped cut wood at boiling time, and for this he gave me a jar of remarkable, amber-colored syrup. Huffy didn’t have Vermont sugar maples. Instead, he relied on native Iowa walnut trees, which he believed made better syrup anyway.
Today, Dr. Farrell is studying the feasibility of these trees in commercial syrup production.
Walnuts typically produce less sap than sugar maples, so their value is in the flavor, which he describes as similar to the finest maple syrup with a hint of nuttiness. His research has been limited to Eastern states, and he’s interested in differences in the volume of sap flow, sugar content and pectin levels in trees from various locations. I emailed him with a couple of questions and an offer of sap from a few southwest Iowa trees.
Making syrup is not difficult; anyone with access to walnut trees at least 8 inches in diameter can do it. Farrell recommended 5/16-inch taps (called “spiles”), which I bought online for $1 each. They’re available in different styles; some designed to hang a bucket from, others with a tube attachment. I chose the latter, in part because we opted to save money by draining into plastic jugs. Buckets would work as well, but should be food grade and covered to keep out foreign material. My set-up has flexible tubing (available at any hardware store) inserted through a hole drilled in the jug’s cap.
Sap with worthwhile sugar content begins to flow in early spring when temperatures rise above freezing during the day and drop below at night. Commercial operators tap early and wait. I did likewise, and found that sap moves a little on bright, sunny days, even at 30 degrees.
In late January, I drilled holes 2 feet above ground in six trees, angling the cordless drill slightly upward to facilitate flow. (Tapping may not be good if trees are intended for lumber. Experts say bore holes heal without harming the tree, but leave a mark that will last for several years.)
My intent was to wait until the first six began producing, then expand to 20 other trees on the same place. I wasn’t expecting much until mid-February, but the fourth was sunny and 40 degrees. My taps, those on the south side, were running at the rate of a drop every four to five seconds and continued until late afternoon. We boiled a gallon to try the syrup, then put out six more taps. The next day was hazy but 55 – another good one. I write this on Friday, also a warm and sunny day, and sap is flowing into a dozen jugs.
This is an experiment and I hadn’t expected so much so early. Other than a sample for Dr. Farrell, I want only enough syrup for our family’s use. Twenty-five gallons of sap will more than provide that, can be obtained without additional taps, and I’ll be pulling the present ones before the strongest flow comes in March. I have no idea how many gallons we could get from a dozen trees, but I simply have no use for it.
Dr. Farrell thinks there may be a niche market for pure black walnut syrup, as opposed to fructose with walnut flavoring added. The only vendor I found online charges $16 for an 8-ounce bottle and claims he sells out to repeat customers within days, so Farrell could be right. I do know wife and I enjoy it with pancakes.
Roy Marshall is a local historian and columnist for the Red Oak Express. He can be contacted at news@redoakexpress.com.
