Gun numbers don’t affect gun deaths
Dear Editor:
Mr. Orear’s op-ed piece in the Dec. 8 edition of the Express was thoughtful and well-written. It was also
deceptive, and missed the point entirely.
He asks us to remember the victims of the recent San Bernardino shootings for what they really are, then goes on to explain they are really victims of those among us who support the Second Amendment. In his piece, he makes no mention of the fact that people operated the firearms used, that those people were radical Muslims and one of them was in this country only because of a
failure of our immigration system. No, in his mind the problem is guns and supporters of the Second Amendment. That’s where he missed the point. The problem, in this case, is not guns. The problem is radical Muslims and bad immigration policy.
Mr. Orear then offered Australia as an example of what responsible, intelligent, enlightened people do to reduce gun violence. He pointed out, correctly, that there have been no mass shootings in Australia since their gun ban legislation was enacted in 1996 and then says “don’t tell me gun restrictions don’t work, because they do.” This is where the deception occurred. I will explain.
The Australian National Homicide Monitoring Program has statistics going back to 1989. These numbers show that in the years between 1989 and 1996, when the legislation was enacted, the average murder rate in Australia was 1.94 per 100,000, and in 2012, that number was calculated to be 1.1 per 100,000. I will leave it to the statisticians to determine whether or not the difference in those numbers is statistically significant. But the murder rate has gone down since the gun ban legislation was enacted, so the legislation works, right? Not so fast.
Let’s look at the murder rate in the United States during the same period. According to the Federal Bureau of Investigation Uniform Crime Report 1950-2010, the murder rate in the United States in 1991 was 9.8 per 100,000. It has trended steadily down since then to 4.8 per 100,000 in 2010. So we see that after the gun ban legislation, Australia saw an 18 percent reduction in the murder rate, and during the same period, the United States saw a reduction of over 50 percent without a gun ban. At the same time, the number of guns in the United States has increased to 112 per 100 people (Small Arms Survey). One must conclude that there is simply no proven correlation between the number of guns and the murder rate.
Arguments like the one advanced by Mr. Orear ignore reality and direct public attention away from the real problems we face, and as such, are fraught with danger to our society. Radical Muslims and bad immigration policy are a much bigger and more immediate threat to America than guns.
Darwin D. Peterson
Red Oak
