Kim Davis denying 14th amendment rights to same sex marriage applicants
Dear Editor:
Mr. Stephens’ editorial on the Tennessee clerk refusing to issue marriage licenses was interesting, especially his analogies--the atheist clerk particularly.
However he did not refer to the language of the first amendment upon which Kim Davis is ostensibly relying for her refusal to issue marriage licenses to gay couples.
As I have written before, when interpreting a document such as the Constitution a good place to start is to read the relevant passages therein—in this case the first Amendment. To paraphrase, it states: Government shall not establish religion, nor shall it prohibit people from freely exercising theirs.
Under this amendment (which includes freedom of speech), as it has so far been interpreted by the final arbiter of meaning (the Supreme Court), Kim Davis is free to exercise her religious beliefs in her home, among her family and friends, in her church, on the street corner, in the various media, etc. However, it seems to me that in her official government capacity (representing the power of the state) she is not free to impose her religious beliefs on others, as she is representing government and it is prohibited from establishing religion--either religion as opposed to non-religious philosophies, or favoring one religion over another.
She is particularly not free to act this way when it denies a legal right. It is particularly ironic that the right she is denying is that of equal protection of the laws (the 14th Amendment)—she is refusing to provide that equal protection.
Steve Turman
Red Oak
