Guest Editorial: Navigating the bureaucracy of bigots
What do most employees get for refusing to do their job?
Fired.
Yes, you guessed it, they lose their job.
They certainly don’t normally become the cause célèbre of the week.
In the curious case of Kim Davis, the Rowan County, Kentucky clerk who has refused to issue marriage licenses to gay couples, for not doing the job she was elected to and swore an oath to do you become a hero of the anti-gay-rights movement and crusader for “religious freedom.”
In light of Davis’ decision, which she has said publicly is based on her religious beliefs and the First Amendment, the clerk has been held in contempt of court for violating a federal judge’s order and jailed. As of late last week, the Rowan County clerk’s office had begun issuing marriage licenses to all as part of a deal with federal prosecutors. But Davis remains steadfast and in jail being quoted as saying God’s law supersedes constitutional law.
Look, I’m not in favor of anyone going to jail for what amounts to civil disobedience or for anyone to lose their job over basically a socio-political philosophy or personal conviction so strong they’d battle in court over it. But this? This stretches far beyond any reasonable limit of what I consider a fair fight over liberty.
Ms. Davis, you had one job here: issue marriage licenses to the humans that request them because you swore to uphold the law. Well, this is the law. You failed.
That’s it. Your faith, and I’m sorry to be the one to tell you this, is an opinion. It’s not a requirement to do the bureaucratic paper work of legally merging two human beings in the eyes of the law. You don’t have to condone anything. You just have to shuffle the papers along.
But I do get it. I get this argument all too well.
Davis has religious convictions that preclude her from fulfilling her job requirements. Sure, they are suspiciously capricious when it comes to discrimination but they are her convictions. I do get that, as hypocritical as that is. I see it all the time. But this clerk has no more legal, moral or sympathetic leg to stand on than George Wallace did at the doors of the University of Alabama 52 years ago.
It’s a curious question, however, to say just how one’s own personal beliefs should affect the doing of one’s job. In some ways it’s perfectly fine for it to inform decisions, but it cannot be at the expense of following the law, said Mills County Recorder Lisa Tallman.
Tallman’s department, in addition to recording, managing and maintaining documents, issues marriage licenses. She’s also a Lutheran with deeply- held religious beliefs. She also couldn’t disagree more with Davis’ decision to not issue marriage licenses to gay couples.
“It is the law and it was signed in by the Supreme Court and I think she should follow the law,” she said. “The Supreme Court is probably smarter than all of us. Do I agree with what she is doing? No, I do not.”
Tallman, who said she supports gay rights, is of the opinion this is a very cut and dried issue for the Kentucky clerk: if you can’t fulfill the duties of the position then you shouldn’t be in the position.
“Either don’t run or resign if it’s against your religious beliefs,” she said. “It’s obvious she’s never met a gay person or had an acquaintance or family member or friends that are gay or otherwise she would understand better and have some compassion. It’s not up to her to judge. Only God has the final say. I think people are more open than this. They’re more enlightened overall.”
History and faith, really, aren’t on Davis’ side. Even if every anti-gay crusade on the right is paying her legal bills.
Discriminating against one group of people simply because your interpretation of your personal beliefs forbids it, in the course of issuing public documents, isn’t just wrong, it’s morally indefensible.
Who’s to say, for argument’s sake, a clerk couldn’t deny a couple, one of which is Jewish and the other Muslim, a marriage license?
A Quaker denying a gun permit?
A vegan refusing to issue hunting licenses?
Outlandish analogies, you say? I disagree. Facetious, maybe, but not outside any realm of possibility when you consider the slippery slope argument that is occurring when one group attempts to wrap bigotry in religious liberty in this all-too- transparent way. I’m not sure Davis and her growing contingent of right-wing opposition to gay rights has really thought this issue through.
Still not convinced? How about this one: an atheist refuses to grant marriage licenses to couples who intend to get married in a church.
Is this still a religious freedom argument now?
That’s the best analogy I can find to highlight the hypocrisy of this crass, discriminatory argument against civil rights. Since when does freedom of religion entitle anyone to deny another their rights?
Ms. Davis, I respect your dedication to your cause if not your decision. You don’t want to issue marriage licenses to gay couples because you think they’re gross or your religious beliefs demand it or you’re a pawn of right wing demagoguery. Whatever, and so be it. So, step aside. Let someone else follow the law.
There really is a separation of church and state in this country. The reason for that is precisely this scenario. And as for the first amendment’s freedom of religion cause? Yeah, that also means freedom from religion. It’s a two-way street that, if people aren’t paying attention, could get them run over.
