Red Oak school board resolves IPIB complaints

 RED OAK – Somewhat reluctantly and by a split vote, the Iowa Public Information Board agreed at a meeting last week to informal resolutions to three pending complaints filed against the Red Oak school board. 

With a 7-1 vote, the Board approved resolutions to complaints filed by Don Rogerson and Jedd Sherman regarding closed sessions at April 10, 14 and May 5 meetings. 

As part of that resolution, the board agreed with an IPIB investigation that revealed they published incomplete and inaccurate agendas from the April meetings.

However, that same investigation exonerated the board of a more serious accusation that they discussed Sherman’s performance as high school principal during the May 5 meeting. 

Under terms of the resolution, the board and Superintendent Terry Schmidt agree to receive additional training on the meetings law and will review information provided by the IPIB. 

In another provision to the resolution, the board agrees a portion of the Iowa code that allows them to discuss personnel evaluations in closed session requires consent of the employee.

While the IPIB’s review of the tape of the May 5 closed session indicated they didn’t discuss Sherman’s performance during that meeting, Rogerson said that only means the conversation occurred during another closed session. 

“Her (IPIB Deputy Director Margaret Johnson) conclusion was the evaluation of the principal had concluded by that May 5 meeting,” Rogerson told the IPIB at its meeting Thursday. “This board … in the past discussed the evaluation of Mr.  Sherman in closed session against his wishes which is against the Iowa open meetings law.”

Rogerson said while he agreed to the resolution, he was disappointed the school board managed to circumvent the law regarding Sherman’s evaluation. 

“I think we still are in a very murky situation,” he said. 

IPIB member Jo Ann Martin voted against the resolution to the Rogerson and Sherman complaints, citing concerns with the school board’s assertion litigation was “imminent,” which gave them cause to close the May 5 meeting. 

Several IPIB members discussed the difference between “imminent” and “probable” litigation. 

“I have a real problem with this imminent and pending issue,” IPIB member Suzann Stewart said. “Too many times, city councils have used this as an excuse to go into closed session.”

Johnson said after reviewing the tape of the May 5 closed session, and considering Sherman was notified in April he would be terminated, she said it was reasonable of the school board to believe litigation was imminent. 

The school board’s concerns were justified when days after the May meeting, Sherman filed paperwork to appeal his termination before an administrative law judge. 

Just before that hearing was scheduled to start, Sherman and the school district agreed to a $100,000 settlement. He has since accepted a teaching position in Council Bluffs. 

And much as Sherman’s legal battles ended with that settlement and a resolution to his open meetings complaint, the IPIB seemed equally inclined to let the matter drop. 

“You could argue this all day, but the gentlemen who filed this signed the agreement,” IPIB member Bill Monroe said. “It’s a judgment call. What is possible and what is imminent?”

After approving the Sherman/Rogerson settlement, the IPIB approved by an 8-0 vote an informal resolution to Margaret Stoldorf’s complaint. 

That complaint stemmed from a June 30 meeting, and again alleged the board published an incomplete agenda.

Initially, the board rejected an informal resolution due to their reluctance to admit fault, but reversed their stance a couple weeks later. 

That resolution also requires the board to complete additional training as well as a promise to publish more complete agendas in the future and to contact the IPIB staff if further questions arise. 

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here