Jury finds Stanton man not guilty of assault charges
RED OAK – Two facts were undisputed in last week’s jury trial at the Montgomery County Courthouse.
One, David Cashatt was knocked unconscious April 13, causing serious injuries to his left eye that will most likely leave him with permanent vision loss.
And two, his niece’s husband, Kevin Kelly, caused those injuries after hitting Cashatt three times with a fist.
What was disputed though was whether Kelly was acting in self-defense or if his reaction to a disabled man old enough to be his father was a brutal act of violence.
It took the 12-member jury about 75 minutes to find Kelly, 32, not guilty of the serious misdemeanor assault with injury charge Tuesday, July 29.
The verdict followed a day-long trial in which Cashatt was referred to as a “father-figure” by Kelly’s wife while his own father testified against him.
Cashatt had gone to Samantha and Kevin Kelly’s rural Stanton home that Sunday evening to fix their broken down truck. Samantha testified Cashatt was a frequent visitor to the home, which also included Kelly’s two young daughters.
However, on this particular day, Cashatt and Kevin started arguing over whether or not to proceed with repair ing the truck. The verbal argument turned physical when according to Kelly, Cashatt approached him with his hand raised.
After hitting Cashatt twice with his fist, Kelly said he hoped the altercation would end.
However, he then testified Cashatt came at him with a hammer.
“At that point, he snapped more than I had ever seen before,” Kelly said. “He said he was going to f’in kill me. I was in fear for my life.”
Cashatt denied ever brandishing a hammer or any kind of weapon, claiming after he was hit twice, he turned around to put his tools away so he could leave.
“I’m not a fighter; never have been,” Cashatt said. “I’m old and worn out and he’s young.”
Cashatt had previously testified he hasn’t been working for several years while receiving disability benefits and that he has suffered a stroke in the past.
Montgomery County Prosecuting Attorney Bruce Swanson said it was during the trial he first heard Cashatt had used a hammer to threaten to Kelly, an occurrence he found unusual.
“I would have been all over (Sheriff’s Deputy) Chris Stephens saying he came after me with a hammer,” Swanson said. “But the only time we have heard about the hammer was this afternoon by the defendant.”
Stephens, the arresting officer and the only one who responded to the scene, testified twice during the trial.
He said Kelly never mentioned being threatened by Cashatt.
“He (Kelly) just said ‘I hit him.’ That’s the only statement he ever made to me,” Stephens. “There was nothing about self-defense. This is the first I heard the word hammer.”
Kelly testified he did tell Stephens about the hammer en route to the Montgomery County Law Enforcement Center, but that the deputy “ignored” him and told him to “save it for the stand.”
Kelly’s attorney, Jack Maylander, also criticized Stephens and his investigative work, pointing out the deputy spent five minutes at the crime scene and that he never took Kelly’s statement.
“I don’t understand how five minutes is enough time to decide a case,” Maylander said. “Obviously, Officer Stephens didn’t spend the needed time to get the facts out of the case.”
After delivering the not-guilty verdict, the jury foreman said they didn’t believe the prosecution proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Kelly wasn’t provoked.
“There were too many loose ends,” he said. “Too many things just didn’t add up.”
Another juror who requested anonymity commented Stephens’ investigation influenced his decision to acquit Kelly.
“I personally didn’t feel like enough questions were asked at the time,” the juror said. “There should have been a more thorough investigation.”
