Salt-Free Solutions
RED OAK — More than a year after the completion of a $1.5 million street and sidewalk renovation project in downtown Red Oak, city officials are encouraging the use of non-salt products as an ice melt to preserve the lifespan of the concrete.
City Administrator Brad Wright said while they are discouraging the use of salt on downtown sidewalks, nothing is being enforced.
“This is just a recommendation, and we understand salt is the best way to remove the ice,” he said. “If [ice] builds up too much and you have no choice but to use salt, we understand. Safety on the sidewalks takes priority.”
While harmful to any concrete, City Engineer Pete Crawford said salt, or sodium chloride, is especially hard on new concrete.
“The chemicals in salt tend to attack new or fresh concrete more so than concrete that has had time to age and become harder and more impenetrable,” Crawford said.
Over time, salt will make the surface of concrete spall, or flake off. Crawford said this is aesthetically unpleasant but also makes sidewalks difficult to clean and can limit its lifespan.
According to Crawford, most sidewalks are built with a 20-year lifespan; however, they realistically are in use for up to 60 years due to the cost of replacement so every precaution should be taken to keep them in good shape.
Finding a concrete-safe ice melt product, though, comes with its own challenges.
According to Berggren Jewelry owner Connie Berggren, it was difficult to find a product to use on such new concrete last winter.
“I know it’s a good thing. I’ve seen my sidewalks at home deteriorate because of the salt. It’s just hard to find the products,” Berggren said. “We spent the money on the work, though, so it’s what we have to do.”
Red Oak Do-It-Center Owner Ron Carlson said the safest way to deal with ice on new concrete is with a traction product, like kitty litter or saw dust, which is given away for free at the store.
Mark Jackson, owner of Hardware Hank, agreed, saying no ice melt product is safe to use on concrete less than a year old. So last year when the concrete was only a few months old, he recommended Traction Grit, a product made of crushed rocks which doesn’t melt ice but does make it less slippery.
According to Jackson, kitty litter and sawdust are better than nothing but tend to absorb water, leaving a mushy mess on the sidewalk. The Traction Grit product can be swept up after the ice is gone.
Because the sidewalks have now had more than a year to age, finding products will be easier.
All the products at the Do-It-Center contain some amount of the salt chemicals, according to Carlson, but some types do say they are safe on certain ages of concrete.
At Hardware Hank, Jackson said Ice No Mor is the recommended product for safely removing ice. While more expensive than salt, it is made with a mixture of chemicals that are safe on concrete more than a year old.
Jackson said he hasn’t carried just salt products in about 10 years because of the dangers to not only concrete but to plants, animals and outdoor metal objects like patio furniture, metal gates and even cars.
Beth Vial of Heartland Insurance said she has used salt alternatives from Hardware Hank and it was just as effective as salt.
“It was such a mess down here for so long (before the sidewalks we redone) that I want to keep it nice,” Vial said. “I did it because that’s what we were told to do and there’s been no problem.”
