Outside the Box: Shutdown is futile, won’t end Obamacare
I spent last week in New York City.
It was my first trip to the city in 20 years, so my wife and I spent a long weekend seeing the sites. The Empire State Building. A play on Broadway. Times Square. Greenwich Village.
But you know what we weren’t able to see?
The Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island. We have the federal government shutdown to thank for that.
National monuments such as Lady Liberty, that beacon of democracy the world over, is considered “nonessential service,” and thusly closed to the public while Congress sorts out its latest political temper tantrum. With the shutdown that began Oct. 1, the National Park Service is presently in a sort of murky gray area. Along with the rest of the country.
The shutdown is the result of a vote in the U.S. House of Representatives, or more importantly, a John Boehner-led, Tea Party supported block of Republicans voting to defund the government in the U.S. House of Representatives. The republican hope? To shutter the fed long enough to derail “Obamacare,” the most comprehensive overhaul of health care in this country since…ever. Why? Because they simply don’t want what two-third’s of Americans, according to several polls, say they do want.
As a result of that ill-advised decision there’s no money available to fund many of the federal government’s departments and it’s 59 federal parks. Most essential agencies will remain functioning during the shutdown with limited staff all the way to full payrolls. Social security checks will still come, air traffic controllers will still keep planes in the air, and our active military, police and emergency services remain intact. Oh, and if you were worried about those congressmen who voted to shutdown the government in the first place not getting paid, don’t worry they still get every penny of their $174,000 salary. For the some 200 members of congress who voted either with tacit approval or outright support to shut down the government, that’s like going on strike and still collecting company money.
YEAH, THAT’LL SHOW ‘EM.
The hostage here isn’t really “Obamacare” as many of the House Republicans would like you to believe. Obamacare, or the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, isn’t tied directly to government funding so defunding the government has no impact on it. “Obamacare” went online Oct. 1 as well. That ship has sailed. Any hope a new spending bill would include provisions to defund the new healthcare law is moot at this point.
Try telling that to the same cabal of republicans whose idea of political action, it appears, is holding their breath until someone, anyone does what they want.
No, the real hostages here are the people these politicians will never see nor deal with: the more than 800,000 furloughed federal employees and the millions who rely on federal assistance to simply live day-to-day. All the while the paychecks of a bunch of rich, mostly white guys still get delivered every month until this is over.
But that’s not even the biggest tragedy of this mess. The federal shutdown may cost congress nothing, save the little respect they think they still garner, but it will cost poor people far more. Federal assistance will continue, but for how long? How do those who need services to live everyday get them during this fiasco, if an error may occur? Navigating “the system” is difficult enough with government employees; it isn’t getting easier without them.
My wife is a therapist. Many of her clients receive federal assistance in some form or another. One of her clients is not getting her educational needs met at her current school and she and her parents are attempting to transfer to a school that better fits their needs. That requires Department of Education assistance and approval. No one is answering those calls.
I have a feeling there’s going to be a lot of calls going unanswered during this shutdown. I hope accountability isn’t going to be one of them.
Joel Stevens is the Associate Editor at The Opinion-Tribune in Glenwood.
