Engineer accused of violating policies
The Mills County Attorney recommended a grand jury trial on allegations that Montgomery County’s newly hired full-time engineer may have shown preferential treatment and broken various policies during road maintenance in 2010 on Montgomery-Page Rd.
According to Mills County Attorney Eric Hansen, Montgomery County Engineer Brad Skinner proceeded with significant grading and maintenance on the road that separates Page and Montgomery counties in May 2010 without prior authorization.
Shortly after the work was completed, property owner Rebecca Wright, wife of Red Oak City Administrator Brad Wright, petitioned to upgrade a portion of the road near their property. Hansen said the work was not billed to any property owner yet cost Page County at least $9,500.
Skinner had been under a sharing agreement with Page County since 2008 but was hired full time in Montgomery County in June when the Page County Board declined to continue the agreement.
Hansen said Skinner was “negligent in his completion of this project” and at worst could be criminally liable.
“The engineer would appear to be in violation of Page County policy and procedures regarding the improvement of Montgomery-Page Rd.,” Hansen said in his letter reviewing the allegations. “The road was re-graded and improved at no expense to the adjoining landowners in violation of county policy. As the connection between the engineer and the homeowners appears to be tenuous, it is less clear if the work was done specifically for private benefit in violation of Iowa Code.”
The initial complaint that led to the investigation was filed with the Page County Board following the roadwork in 2010, and the Board handed the matter to their county attorney, who because of conflict of interests, asked Hansen to review the matter.
Hansen released his findings in April of this year. The Page County Board discussed the matter at their July 30 meeting, but due to the delay in receiving Hansen’s recommendation and the questionable relevance, decided unanimously not to take action.
“My job was just to lay it out for the policy makers,” Hansen said. “They have to weigh the cost benefit analysis and decide what is best for them. It’s not my community; I am supportive of any choice made by the policy makers, though.”
Following a Clarinda Herald-Journal article on the matter, Skinner released a letter explaining the situation.
He said the roadwork and upgrade request were two separate matters, both of which were addressed by both the Page and Montgomery County Boards.
The roadwork was routine maintenance on a “Level B” dirt road, which, according to Skinner’s letter, was essentially to reshape the road by moving dirt to make it passable.
“This type of maintenance activity, without plans or specifications, is done annually on five to 20 miles of road in most counties — Page and Montgomery included,” Skinner said. “Boards of Supervisors typically do not get involved with such routine maintenance, but both were advised in this case due to the shared roadway and the opportunity for crews to have cross-training from the adjacent county (work together).”
In response to the upgrade requested by the Wrights, Skinner said they did in fact pay for the work, contrary to Hansen’s letter.
“In this case, the Wrights paid for all improvements beyond a “Level B” status for the portion they desired upgraded and after the “Level B” maintenance work was done. Estimates for the upgrade costs were initially prepared following Montgomery County’s policy as Montgomery County had maintenance responsibility on this segment of the road.”
Payment was divided 50 percent to each county and was received in October 2010.
Montgomery County Supervisor Bryant Amos said he is in agreement with the contents of Skinner’s letter and the Board will not be discussing it any further.
“We addressed all the questions (in 2010) but there was no official action that needed to be taken,” Amos said. “I looked into the allegations that favors were being done, but it was really just a big rumor mill.
I think the Mills County Attorney did a poor job looking up the facts; he seemed to base his letter on the rumors… I don’t understand why he would put this out without talking to the people involved in the project.”
