What's Going On: Carlyle’s resignation should be the first of many for Association

Red Oak Chamber and Industry Association Executive Director Darrell Steven Carlyle has resigned; 13 more people should follow his lead.

Carlyle’s resignation represents an epidemic failure on the part of the Association’s Board of Directors, systematic of a flawed organizational structure.

With Carlyle out of the picture, the entire board needs to resign, restructure and start again.

If not, whoever is hired to replace Carlyle is pre-destined to fail.

When members of Red Oak’s Chamber and Industrial Development boards decided to merge into one organization, I was equally shocked and impressed by the forward-thinking concept. Combining two organizations that share a similar goal of promoting Red Oak and pooling their collective resources seemed obviously brilliant.

However, in my experience, this kind of radical change is difficult to embrace, regardless of the obvious benefits. But for Red Oak, there was no resistance: radical change was needed, so that is what happened.

The timing was essential. Economic recession and downsizing was sweeping the country, ushering in double-digit unemployment and Red Oak was not immune.

But what separated Red Oak from the other communities of its size was its ability to recover.

CDS closes? No biggie, we will have DirecTV in there in six months and add a couple more industries to the north side of town around the same time. Pamida wants to close? I don’t think so. With the sales pitch of unmatched fervor, Shopko officials changed their minds and decide to convert the store instead of close it.  Theatre’s going to close because the town’s too small? Forget it. The town will buy it and run it as a not-for-profit organization.

Red Oak is different because Red Oak doesn’t accept the status quo. It will change and evolve to make sure the community survives and thrives.

With drastic change though, there has to be a willingness to step back and consider if more improvements can be made.

That time is right now.

A 13-member board is a disaster waiting to happen. That’s 13-different agendas splintered every direction and 13 positions having to be filled.

There hasn’t been an actual contested election for the board because they practically have to beg and recruit volunteers to serve to begin with, a byproduct of having 13 positions.

If the county, city and school districts can all efficiently operate with just five-member boards, I’m sure the Association can as well. The smaller number will not only eliminate the problem of finding people to serve, it will also further empower the current members while at the same time, providing a more definite direction to the Director.

And maybe you go with seven to get a little more representation. Regardless, 13 is a crazy number which is why everyone should resign and start a new board. Let me add here this is not a commentary on any individual’s ability or performance as a current board member. I’m not casting any judgment or offering an opinion on their performance, simply the structure of this organization.

Another change that needs to be considered is maintaining leadership positions for a longer period. Electing a new board president every year is another really bad idea. By the time the new president learns the ropes and starts to feel confident in what they are doing, it’s time to pass the gavel and train the new person.

Red Oak is at a crossroads.

With Carlyle’s resignation, the Chamber and Industry Association board has a difficult decision to make.

One road is littered with smiles, handshakes and pats on the backs. Lots of platitudes and atta boys down that road. The path is smooth and somewhere in the distant background, you’ll hear violin music playing, all while the ship splinters in two atop a giant iceberg, seconds before it sinks to a watery grave deep in the Atlantic Ocean.

The other path is not a pleasant looking one. It requires radical change and some people’s feelings (pride) will be bruised. It will require us to place the interest of the community in front of our own priorities. It will require compromise and renewed commitment by a lot of people.

It will be hard to travel down that path, but for Red Oak to continue to grow like it has the past couple years, for Red Oak to continue to thrive when others barely survive, it is a path that must be taken.

It’s again time to embrace radical change.

Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express and Glenwood Opinion-Tribune. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here