What's Going On: Banning driving while buzzed a good idea

A couple weeks ago, the National Transportation and Safety Board recommended states lower their blood alcohol content requirements for a drunk driving charge.

As many of you may recall, the drunk-driving level was at 10 percent, but similar federal “recommendations” resulted in it being lowered to the current .08 level enforced in all 50 states.

For the record, it took 21 years for all 50 states to change their laws.

But now, the NTSB, which has no legal authority and simply advocates (recommends) for safety improvements for all transportation modes, is urging we start the process all over and drop the limit even more to half of what it was just a few years ago.

My opinion in three words: It’s about time.

More than 100 countries worldwide have already taken this step, including several in Europe and South America, as well as Russia and Australia.

When Australia made the change, alcohol related traffic fatalities dropped by up to 18 percent in various regions.

In their report recommending the change, the NTSB stated the chance of being involved in a traffic accident increased to more than 100 percent with a .08 BAC, but it also increases to nearly 40 percent at .05.

That’s a significant jump, not surprising considering once the BAC hits that level, eyesight begins to be impaired.

In other words, bad eyes results in bad driving. Shocking.

However, everything the NTSB is stating isn’t news to anyone who has ever drank more than one alcoholic beverage at one sitting.

I feel fairly confident in my driving tenure, I’ve never driven drunk by current legal standards. I have no way of verifying that beyond never being pulled over, ticketed or involved in an accident while under the influence of alcohol.

With that said, I do know I’ve probably driven at or near the .05 level and thinking afterwards, I shouldn’t have driven.

I’m sure I’m not alone, as many have are guilty of “driving buzzed,” as frankly, it doesn’t take much.

For an average sized woman, a couple glasses of wine in an hour will push you to the .05 level. For a 180-pound man, try four beers in an hour.

Sounds like a typical chicken-wing dinner at the local bar to me.

But that doesn’t make it any less irresponsible. If eyesight is affected and the chance of being in a wreck, which could injure those around you, increase nearly 40 percent, you don’t need to be driving. Have a cup of coffee and wait an hour or two, call someone, get a cab, walk. I don’t care, just don’t jeopardize my life or anyone else’s for that matter.

One useful number provided by the NTSB study was this: 10,000. That’s how many people die each year in alcohol-related accidents. And while increased enforcement combined with lowering the BAC to .08 has dropped that number from nearly twice that, it is still unacceptable.

Based on similar legislative changes in other countries (see Australia), the NTSB estimates they can reduce the number of fatalities by 1,000 a year, or 10 percent.

Understandably, there is some opposition to this proposal, specifically from the people who make more money when you have two, or three, or even four glasses of wine at dinner.

Restaurant industry officials have responded with phrases like “criminalize perfectly responsible behavior,” and how the proposal “does nothing to stop hardcore drunk drivers from getting behind the wheel.”

So in short, federal officials are urging restrictive legislation in the name of saving lives while advocacy/lobbying groups are discouraging it in the name of personal freedoms while criticizing it because it doesn’t prevent every single possible related crime.

Wow, that sounds familiar. 

But unlike gun control legislation, this change will probably be passed as there is no NRA in its path and no one is confusing tougher DWI laws with an attempt to ban all alcohol sales.

Also, federal officials have the proverbial ace in the hole, should they feel motivated to use it: withholding federal highway dollars to states that don’t make the change.

And it’s about time.

Driving buzzed is unnecessary and dangerous and certainly not a constitutionally protected right. 

It’s time for it to end.

Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express and Glenwood Opinion-Tribune. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here