What's Going On: The obnoxious side of the First Amendment

A Jewish-sponsored media company recently produced a documentary about the status of the neo-Nazi movement in our modern society.

While international in its scope, the documentary focused on several groups and their leaders that are thriving in America.

When discussing the prevalence of the anti-semitic, Holocaust-denying, white nationalist groups in America, the documentary’s producer explained they were difficult to control and eradicate because of the First Amendment.

 In many European countries, simply publicly questioning whether the Holocaust ever happened, or voicing support of Adolph Hitler and his regime can land a person in jail. Even giving the one-armed Nazi salute in Germany can result in spending some time with law enforcement. As a result, well-organized and publicized neo-Nazi groups just aren’t as numerous outside the U.S.

It was interesting listening to this Jewish film producer speak seemingly with regret about how the First Amendment prevented the abolishment of these hate groups as if it was some sort of legal roadblock.

Obviously, to someone of Jewish descent, these kinds of organizations and the messages they espouse are incredibly upsetting and offensive.

Yet when I listened to this foreign filmmaker speak of the First Amendment as if it was a problem, I found a new appreciation for the unique freedoms we take for granted in this country.

Sometimes, those freedoms come at a cost and in the case of freedom of press and expression, that cost can be emotional distress stemming from hate-filled propaganda.

But that’s how it is in America. We are willing to accept the trade off of the occasional hurt feelings and associated emotional distress in exchange for the right to say what we want, no matter how tasteless.

And there’s a bunch of Baptists who are as happy as neo-Nazis about that fact.

Westboro Baptist Church and their anti-homosexual agenda made news again with the announcement last week that they have joined forces with the American Civil Liberties Union in a class action suit that includes Red Oak Police Chief Drue Powers and Montgomery County Sheriff Joe Sampson as defendants.

Powers and Sampson are accused of enforcing a flag desecration law the ACLU claims was deemed unconstitutional. The Baptist Church protestors wanted to stomp on the U.S. flag during demonstrations in Red Oak before the funerals for Milton Lanz and Sgt. James Skalberg.

Predictably, the reaction to the lawsuit has been one of hostility directed toward the Baptists. Powers has claimed ignorance regarding the court ruling as justification for not allowing the protesters to stomp on the flag, but based on the level of public support shown so far, he doesn’t need to make excuses.

This is one lawsuit local taxpayers probably won’t mind paying for. Most residents in this area, with their strong sense of patriotism, would rather pay an out-of-court settlement rather than allow a bunch of out-of-town radicals desecrate the flag.

And in that sense, local residents share common ground with that Jewish filmmaker in their at least occasional distaste for the First Amendment.

Baptists and Nazis are both allowed to share their message because of the First Amendment. The protection offered is universal.

And that is the ugly, dark side of the U.S. Constitution and Bill of Rights. They apply to everyone.

While that may create the occasional bad taste when I see children or Nazis promoting hate-filled and intolerant beliefs, its one I’m willing to accept.

Only when the First Amendment protects the most disgusting, unpleasant individuals and organizations in this country can we be truly sure it will always protect and apply to the rest of us as well.

Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express and Glenwood Opinion-Tribune. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here